The police can seize items of your property and conduct searches as part of their investigation. If they didn’t have this power, you can imagine that it would make their ability to do their job much more difficult—and, at times, almost impossible. There are, however, specific procedures that officers must follow, and they must work within certain parameters so they do not infringe on your rights. You have a constitutional right to be safe from an unreasonable search or seizure. While the police may have the ability to seize and search your phone, you may wonder whether they also have the ability to compel you to unlock your phone. Do you have to assist them with their investigation? At what point does their power go too far?

Section 487.02 of the Criminal Code allows judicial officials who have authorized or issued a warrant to also order someone to provide assistance “if the person’s assistance may reasonably be considered to be required to give effect to the authorization or warrant.” In theory, this means that if a search warrant is issued, then you can be ordered to assist in a way that makes the search meaningful i.e. you can be asked to unlock your phone, if your phone is the focus of the search.

But not so fast. In practice, it is not as straightforward. Now that smartphones have become prevalent in our daily lives, the courts have begun to deal with this issue over the last few years.

In 2017, the Ontario Court of Justice heard R. v. Talbot. Mr. Talbot was charged with second degree murder and his phone was seized in order for it to undergo a forensic search. His phone was protected, and the police could not access information on the phone without risking its erasure. The Crown then brought an assistance order application under section 487.02 of the Criminal Code to compel Mr. Talbot to provide the screen lock passcode in the form of a “swipe pattern.” Justice Applegate first considered whether the “person” referred to in section 487.02 includes an accused person or only refers to third parties and non-targets of investigations being compelled to assist. Justice Applegate was not prepared to find that accused persons are excluded from this section. Parliament could have specifically excluded them but chose not to, leaving the door open for accused persons to be the subject of an assistance order in the future.

That being said, Justice Applegate recognized that the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms factors into the analysis of whether or not to issue an assistance order. The presiding judicial official must consider whether it is in the best interests of the administration of justice to issue it; this consideration involves the balancing of the accused’s rights to privacy and the state’s interest in investigating criminal activity, as well as the potential breach of Charter rights. Ultimately, it was found that compelling Mr. Talbot to provide his “swipe pattern” would infringe on his section 7 Charter right to life, liberty, and security of the person in a way that was not in accordance with the principles of fundamental justice. The order would contravene his right to silence. He would not be able to choose whether he wanted to communicate with police; he would be forced to do so with the threat of additional charges if he did not participate. More broadly, it would breach his right against self-incrimination; he would be asked to communicate information against his will in order to help the state with his own prosecution. It should be noted that the Crown had offered “use immunity” to protect Mr. Talbot’s rights with respect to the swipe pattern itself, the fact that it unlocked the phone, his connection to the swipe pattern, and any statements made while providing the pattern to police. While Justice Applegate acknowledged that certain immunity could alleviate Charter violations in these situations, he rejected the immunity offered by the Crown as a safeguard. It did not protect against the use of any potential incriminating information on the phone—it only applied to Mr. Talbot’s connection to the phone. That was simply not enough to ensure that Mr. Talbot’s rights were respected.

A second case, R. v. Shergill, appeared in the Ontario Court of Justice the following year with a judgment rendered in early 2019. Mr. Shergill was charged with multiple sexual and child pornography offences. A search warrant was issued for his phone, but the phone was password-protected. Similar to Talbot, the police couldn’t access the information on the phone without risking its destruction. Like Justice Applegate, Justice Downes found that section 487.02 did not preclude an accused from being the subject of an assistance order. Justice Downes also found that there was a violation of section 7 of the Charter. Mr. Shergill’s liberty would be deprived in a way that is not in accordance with the right against self-incrimination and the right to silence. Revealing his phone’s password would have a significant incriminatory effect on Mr. Shergill; he would be a target of an allegation assisting the state in proving the allegation. He could be providing information “which is potentially crucial to the success of any prosecution against him, and which could not be obtained without the compelled disclosure of what currently exists only in his mind” (para. 39). Mr. Shergill would not be afforded the choice of whether or not to speak to police. The assistance order was not granted.

As we continue to rely more heavily on our phones and other electronic devices to communicate and live our lives, there will likely be more cases like these winding their way through the courts. As it currently stands, the courts have left open the possibility that an accused could be compelled to assist with an investigation. As Justice Downs acknowledged in Shergill, if there was an outright prohibition on an accused’s assistance, DNA warrants, breathalyzers, and fingerprinting could not exist. Yet the context of unlocking cell phones is particularly troublesome, because it involves compelled speech. There must be adequate protections to an accused’s Charter rights in order to justify putting them in such a precarious position.

By |2023-08-11T10:34:18+00:00October 14th, 2020|Criminal Defence|

5/5 - (3 votes)

Criminal Lawyers Association
Toronnto Lawyers Association
Law Society of Ontario
Criminal Lawyers Association
Toronnto Lawyers Association
Law Society of Ontario
Excellent5.0 Based on 148 reviews fromE ME M ★★★★★ Igor is, without a doubt, one of the top lawyers in the country. When I approached him with my case, I was uncertain about the outcome. However, Igor's exceptional support and guidance alleviated my concerns. He was always available to answer my questions, and his flexible payment plan was a huge relief.What impressed me most was Igor's unwavering confidence and commitment. He assured me that he never backs down from trials, and his reputation precedes him. This is what kept me at peace through out the case.Throughout the process, Igor handled my case with utmost professionalism, keeping me informed every step of the way. His office was incredibly helpful, providing regular updates and ensuring a seamless experience.I had 2 charges which have severe consequences but the outcome of my case exceeded my expectations, thanks to Igor's expertise and dedication. I couldn't recommend him more highly, especially for those facing criminal cases. Igor truly goes above and beyond, and his services are unparalleled.x NoVAx NoVA ★★★★★ Igor did amazing job, I was very stressed out when I found out I had been charged with SA but every step of the Igor was there for me and was looking out for my best interest. He was always responsive and kept me up to date with all updates given to him and directly to me, if he wasn’t available he always had someone update me. Got me off my charges and helped me save jail time. Igor is the guy you need if you’re involved in any sort of similar situationforrzen Sherzadforrzen Sherzad ★★★★★ Dear Igor, I just wanted to take a moment to express my heartfelt gratitude for everything you’ve done for us. Your hard work and dedication in getting my husband released from jail mean the world to me. I’m so incredibly happy right now, and I truly believe you are the best lawyer ever!Your expertise and support throughout this process have been invaluable, and I can’t thank you enough. I will definitely be referring you to all my friends and family, and I’ll be leaving a 5-star review to share how amazing you are. Thank you again for everything! 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ we are so grateful for you thank you so much Igor you saved Jerome life your are truly the greatest!!!Michie FedericoMichie Federico ★★★★★ Igor and his team were absolutely amazing in helping my daughter out with everything. There were easy to get a hold off and there work is absolutely amazing I highly recommend him and his team.Tony OhTony Oh ★★★★★ Absolutely exceptional! My lawyer provided unwavering support, professionalism, and expertise throughout my case. Igor guided me every step of the way, ensuring I felt heard and protected. I couldn’t have asked for a better advocate. Highly recommended!nnn nnnnnn nnn ★★★★★ I'm very glad that Igor Vilkhov was my lawyer in solving my difficult problems. He is a real high-class professional. Thanks to Igor and his team ( special thanks to Daniel Slobodsky). My case was successfully completed. Excellent professional work with positive results. Highest recommendations! Roman M.Richard HyltonRichard Hylton ★★★★★ I cannot thank Igor enough for his amazing service. I was facing a serious charge that felt overwhelming. But Igor’s calm demeanour and level headed approach to my case gave me reassurance.Thanks to his amazing work everything was completely withdrawn, which allowed me to reclaim my life. I feel free to move forward without the weight of this hanging on my head. Thank God for Igor’s services! If you need a criminal lawyer, hire him!Ryan WiltonRyan Wilton ★★★★★ Igor Vilkhov and his associate Joel Prajs has been an absolutely amazing lawyers to work with, they've saved me copious amounts of grief on my legal matters.Their diligence to my matter and their ability to work with me and my schedule were greatly appreciated.I'd give them higher than 5 star rating if I could, my new number 1 lawyer!!Dennis ParkDennis Park ★★★★★ Igor is an absolute fantastic lawyer and I would highly recommend. I was facing some serious charges and Igor not only got all my charges withdrawn, he was very caring and informative through out the whole process. I owe him very dearly for getting me a second chance at life.Jodi HixonJodi Hixon ★★★★★ My name is Gary Hixon I've had Igor as my lawyer, and he did nothing but worked on my case and he got me worried at first , but because of COVID the first time I actually met him was when he hit my case out of the ball park. He's a great man I recommend him too all. Thank you Igor.Big DOWNEYYYBig DOWNEYYY ★★★★★ Greatness!!!! Mr.Igor Vilkhov and his team did a tremendous job on my stabbing case! He saved my life today I was facing years in the penitentiary for assault and he literally got it reduced to 2 years house arrest. He was an absolute pleasure to work with has a great attitude & I highly recommend him to everyone looking for a defense lawyer. He is definitely one of the TOP LAWYERS in Toronto! Thank you so muchTristan SmithTristan Smith ★★★★★ Igor has been a tremendous help and has saved my life, not just metaphorically. I can't think of a better and more competent person (and team) to have behind you! I just walked out of the courthouse acquitted after trial. I was facing five years in jail. Thank you so much.Zabi AkbariZabi Akbari ★★★★★ Mr. Vilkhov represented me in a trial today and I was found not guilty. I am a professional and this caused a lot of emotional turmoil for me. Igor was amazing during the trial, he absolutely nailed it. Thank you for getting my life back.MARK SINGHMARK SINGH ★★★★★ Igor Vilkov, was the calm in a storm that I thought would never pass. Mr Vilkov always made sure to answer all my questions a concerns . When incarcerated Mr Vilkov always kept in touch with my family . Without his expertise I would have never received such a favourable sentence . He was able to get me a non costodaial sentence for 3 serious charges that could have had me locked up for 2 years or more . Mr Vilkov truly cares about his client's a there family and not just about fees . I would recommend Mr Vilkov to anyone who has been charged he is a true professional.Thompson RanjitsinghThompson Ranjitsingh ★★★★★ Very great SA lawyer very reliable .he will do a very good job in getting you acquitted. Thanks a million igorJoshua RJoshua R ★★★★★ Best lawyer out there thank you for fighting my caseLydia RanjitsinghLydia Ranjitsingh ★★★★★ He's a very good lawyers, he got my son charges drop.Thank youthompson “Aaliyah R.” ranjitsinghthompson “Aaliyah R.” ranjitsingh ★★★★★ KK ★★★★★ So thankful that he got the job done and with reasonable pricing, he was so helpful and respectful throughout the whole process. 5 stars well earned.Sami Life Style (SamSam)Sami Life Style (SamSam) ★★★★★ I was facing very serious charges and was represented by Mr. Prajs. Mr. Prajs and the whole team at Vilkhov law vigorously defended me at trial and my charges were withdrawn. I can recommend Mr. Prajs and the whole Vilkhov team to anyone facing serious allegations.Ysabel AtienzaYsabel Atienza ★★★★★ Igor displays a level of professionalism, knowledge and dedication that puts his clients at ease during a very stressful time. His expertise in criminal law is unparalleled. What sets him apart is his unwavering commitment to his clients. He genuinely cares about his clients’ well-being and will go above and beyond for you!Kevin DKevin D ★★★★★ Igor is a great lawyer and has provided valuable guidance throughout my experience with him. He has always been honest and straightforward which I appreciate very much. I would recommend him to anyone looking for a successful outcome.Narmatha SNarmatha S ★★★★★ Igor is a dedicated and intelligent lawyer, known for his commitment to his clients.I've witnessed firsthand his incredible work ethic and professionalism, which sets a high standard in the legal field. His ability to meticulously research cases and articulate arguments convincingly is truly impressive!Fred BalmerFred Balmer ★★★★★ Experience with Vilkhov Law was great, Igor made all my charges get dropped without any issues. I would highly recommend this firm to everyonejs_loader

CONTACT US

“Caring, honest, and highly knowledgeable.”

Contact Igor for a Free Consultation!

Please contact us online for a free consultation.
Go to Top