GettyImages
Key Takeaways
- Manslaughter in Ontario is a form of culpable homicide distinct from murder and infanticide.
- Two main categories exist: voluntary manslaughter (provocation/heat of passion) and involuntary manslaughter (unlawful act or criminal negligence).
- Leading cases like R v Creighton, R v Jobidon, and Smithers v R define key elements such as foreseeability, consent, and causation.
- Sentencing for manslaughter in Ontario ranges from no minimum (unless a firearm is involved) to life imprisonment, with aggravated or domestic cases often resulting in 7–12 years.
- Possible defences include provocation, lack of foreseeability, and diminished responsibility.
- If charged, it is essential to consult an experienced defence lawyer.
Table of Contents
- Statutory Framework for Ontario Manslaughter Charges
- Manslaughter vs Murder (and Infanticide)
- Types of Manslaughter
- Key Canadian Cases Defining Manslaughter
- Sentencing for Manslaughter in Ontario
- Manslaughter Defences and Sentencing Mitigation
- Final Thoughts on Manslaughter Charges in Ontario
- FAQ about Manslaughter Charges
Anyone accused of a crime related to the death of another person could be in serious legal trouble in Canada. Charges ranging from murder to manslaughter to infanticide carry varying levels of moral blameworthiness and criminal punishment. If you or a family member is facing manslaughter charges, you’re in the right place. This guide will tell you everything you need to know; we’ll cover legal categories, mens rea, potential defences, and sentencing information, all in the context of Ontario.
Statutory Framework for Ontario Manslaughter Charges
First and foremost, it’s critical to understand the statutory framework in place concerning manslaughter, murder charges, and infanticide.
Under Section 222 of the Criminal Code, a person has committed homicide when they cause the death of another human being.
Subsections 2-6 of this same section break things down a bit further. They state that homicide may be considered culpable (legally liable) or non-culpable (not legally liable). The culpable forms of homicide are murder, manslaughter, and infanticide.
Manslaughter vs Murder (and Infanticide)
The main difference between murder, manslaughter, and infanticide lies in who is involved, the intent behind the homicide, and more. The table below will give you a quick look at the differences in the context of Canada (including Ontario):
| Term | Definition | Legal Source |
|---|---|---|
| Murder | When someone kills another person with intent and planning. | Section 231 of the Criminal Code |
| Manslaughter | When an individual commits homicide in the heat of passion caused by sudden provocation. | Section 232 of the Criminal Code |
| Infanticide | When a female causes the death of their newborn baby through a purposeful act or omission. To be classified as true infanticide, the mother must be in the birth recovery process or mentally affected by the consequences of childbirth or breastfeeding. | Section 233 of the Criminal Code |
Types of Manslaughter
GettyImages
Manslaughter in Ontario (and more generally, Canada) falls into a few key categories, including:
Voluntary Manslaughter
A crime is deemed voluntary manslaughter when someone dies due to another person’s attempt to harm, but not kill, them. A common situation where this may apply is in a brawl that went too far and resulted in one of the parties losing their life.
Involuntary Manslaughter
On the other hand, involuntary manslaughter is when someone unintentionally kills another without any intent due to:
- Unlawful actions
- Negligence
- Recklessness
Involuntary manslaughter is broken down into two subtypes:
- Unlawful-act (constructive) manslaughter: Death which is the result of an unlawful action (assault or battery, for instance) where the accused had no intent to kill. The referenced unlawful action should be dangerous in nature, meaning that it must carry a risk of substantial bodily harm.
- Criminal negligence manslaughter: Death where the accused shows a deviation from a reasonable standard of care. In layman’s terms, criminal negligence causing death refers to situations where an alleged offender acted in a way that most would consider dangerous. Most of the time, this charge stems from grossly negligent or reckless conduct.
Key Canadian Cases Defining Manslaughter
A few leading Supreme Court of Canada cases help define these categories more precisely:
- R v Creighton – Mens rea (1993): A man injected cocaine into a woman, and she died as a result. This case shed light on objective foreseeability in manslaughter in Canada. For unlawful-act manslaughter, the required mens rea (mental state) is that a reasonable person could foresee their actions causing serious or lasting bodily harm. The Court indicated that the accused individual doesn’t need to have foreseen death itself.
- Smithers v R (1978): A man kicked someone else after a hockey game, and they subsequently choked and died. In establishing causation, the Crown has to show that the act was a contributing cause of death outside the de minimis range – meaning more than a trivial contribution.
- R v Jobidon – Consent Defence (1991): A man was charged with manslaughter after a fist fight. This case zeroed in on the limits of consent as an assault defence. In a consensual fight, once serious or non-trivial bodily harm results, consent is vitiated (negated) and can no longer be used as a defence.
Speak with a defence lawyer for more information.
“Manslaughter cases in Ontario are among the most complex areas of criminal law. The difference between a conviction for murder and manslaughter often comes down to intent, foreseeability, and how the evidence is presented in court. Having skilled legal representation is critical to ensure that your rights are fully protected.” — Joel Prajs, Criminal Defence Lawyer at Vilkhov Law
Sentencing for Manslaughter in Ontario
Let’s take a look at the law surrounding a manslaughter sentence in Canada. Legal experts look to the Criminal Code for manslaughter in Canada, including Ontario. Section 236 states that the crime of manslaughter is an indictable offence with a maximum penalty of life in prison.
As for penalties for manslaughter with a firearm in Ontario, the mandatory minimum sits at 4 years in prison. If there is no firearm, there’s no mandatory minimum to observe. In these cases, the sentence will be determined based on several different factors:
- The nature of the illegal act or negligence.
- How much harm was inflicted.
- The accused’s personal circumstances.
Sentences for aggravated manslaughter and domestic cases range from 7 to 12 years in Ontario.
Examples of aggravating circumstances include abuse of power, weapon use, extreme recklessness, and more. And mitigating factors may include lack of a criminal record, mental illness, and provocation.
Manslaughter Defences and Sentencing Mitigation
Those who have been accused of homicide aren’t without options. For instance, when provocation can be proven, lawyers may use a heat-of-passion manslaughter defence in an attempt to reduce a murder charge to manslaughter. Then there are contextual and factual defences: foreseeability (R v Creighton, 1993), the issue of consent (R v Jobidon, 1991), diminished responsibility, and more. Not only do these defences and mitigating factors affect a case’s outcome, but they also affect the resulting sentence.
Final Thoughts on Manslaughter Charges in Ontario
A manslaughter charge comes with numerous nuances that ultimately dictate how the case is treated in court and defended by lawyers. If you or someone you know is facing the GTA manslaughter charges, it’s critical to talk to a skilled Barrie, Mississauga, Brampton, or Newmarket criminal lawyer at Vilkhov Law. Considering the steep consequences of these charges, it only makes sense to partner with the best possible defence lawyer you can find.
FAQ about Manslaughter Charges
What is the difference between manslaughter and murder in Ontario?
Murder requires intent to kill, while manslaughter usually involves killing without intent, often due to provocation, negligence, or unlawful acts.
What is voluntary manslaughter in Canada?
Voluntary manslaughter occurs when someone kills another in the heat of passion caused by sudden provocation.
What is involuntary manslaughter?
Involuntary manslaughter happens when a person unintentionally causes death through unlawful acts, negligence, or recklessness.
What are the sentencing rules for manslaughter in Ontario?
Manslaughter carries a maximum penalty of life in prison. If a firearm is used, there is a mandatory minimum of four years.
Can consent be used as a defence in manslaughter cases?
In Canada, consent is limited. As established in R v Jobidon, consent does not apply when serious bodily harm occurs in a fight.
Why should I hire a defence lawyer if I’m facing manslaughter charges?
Manslaughter cases are complex, involving intent, causation, and case law. A skilled defence lawyer can help build a strong case and protect your rights.
