what is preliminary hearing

A preliminary hearing is a hearing held by the court to determine if there’s enough evidence for a case to go to trial. A preliminary hearing is also known as a preliminary inquiry – the two phrases can be used interchangeably.

Who Is Entitled to a Preliminary Hearing?

Not every charge entitles the accused to a preliminary inquiry. Preliminary inquiries are only acceptable in cases of serious nature or indictable offences such as murder, rape, acts of terrorism, robbery, treason, drug trafficking, etc. Most individuals accused of minor crimes have no right to a preliminary inquiry.

An accused has the right to opt for a preliminary hearing or decide not to have one. For example, suppose the accused chooses to waive their right to a preliminary inquiry. In that case, they’ll be accepting that there’s enough evidence for the case to go to trial with no need for a preliminary inquiry.

However, this doesn’t necessarily mean admission of guilt.

The accused can decide to waive their right to a preliminary inquiry in some cases, but the Crown Attorney can also decide otherwise. When that happens, the attorney can conduct a preliminary hearing regardless of the decision of the accused.

However, the accused should be aware that conducting a preliminary hearing comes with certain risks. For example, let’s say the Crown Attorney presents credible evidence that discloses another charge other than the one brought before the judge. In that case, the judge may also decide to have the accused tried for the new charge.

This is why the accused should always work with a qualified lawyer for legal advice regarding their right to a preliminary hearing. Such a lawyer is in a better position to decide whether the accused should waiver their right to a preliminary hearing or not.

Scenarios Where a Preliminary Hearing Favours the Accused

There are some situations where a preliminary hearing can be advantageous to the accused. They include:

● When the accused wants to make a pretrial application or charter argument based on the evidence from the witnesses.
● When the accused knows that some Crown witnesses may fail to attend the trial hence needs their evidence recorded before trial.
Scenarios Where a Preliminary Hearing Doesn’t Favour the Accused

A preliminary hearing won’t favour the accused under the following circumstances:

● When the accused can’t afford a lawyer.
● The preliminary hearing would further delay the trial.
● The preliminary hearing would make the prosecution aware of their weaknesses and give them a chance to fix that before the trial begins.

Conditions for a Preliminary Hearing

A preliminary inquiry can only be held when the following conditions are met:
● The accused is charged with an indictable offence or a hybrid offence where the Crown elects to proceed by way of indictment.
● The accused is facing a jail term of not less than 14 years if convicted.
● The accused has the option of choosing their trial at the Superior Court of Justice.
● The accused or Crown has requested a preliminary hearing.

What Does a Preliminary Hearing Entail?

Here’s what happens at a preliminary hearing:

The prosecutor presents crucial evidence against the accused at a preliminary hearing and calls witnesses to provide evidence against the accused. The court allows the defence lawyer to cross-examine the witnesses brought forward by the Crown prosecutor.

The prosecutor only needs to convince the court that credible evidence exists to present and convict the accused. But they don’t need to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the accused is guilty. This is why judges dismiss very few cases at this stage – most proceed to trial.

The court then reviews the prosecutor’s evidence and witness testimony and decides if it’s sufficient for trial. If the court finds that the evidence is sufficient, it sends the case to trial. The court will then set a trial date if the accused pleads not guilty.

However, if the court finds the evidence insufficient, it dismisses the case and discharges the accused.

Significance of a Preliminary Hearing

A preliminary hearing:

● Allows the accused to understand the weight of the case against them.
● Allows the accused to plan their defence at trial.
● Offers an opportunity to resolve the case before trial.

What if More Than One Person Is Accused?

There are cases where the Crown prosecutor accuses more than one person of an indictable offence. In such a case, slightly different conditions must be met to proceed to a preliminary hearing.

Firstly, it requires only one of the accused persons to request a preliminary hearing, and all the other co-accused persons will have to attend the hearing. The co-accused can also request the court to try them separately by submitting a severance application.

However, submitting a severance application is not always easy because several conditions have to be met for the court to accept the application. The conditions include:

● There must be valid reasons that make it unfair for an individual to be tried with other co-accused persons.
● There’s little or no public interest in having the co-accused persons tried together.

If the court accepts the severance application of an accused, their case will be decided separately. Additionally, they won’t have to go to a preliminary inquiry with the co-accused.

If you’ve been charged with a serious crime, don’t risk appearing before the court without legal representation. You need an experienced criminal defence lawyer in Toronto to fight for you. Contact Vilkhov Law today!

By |2023-08-11T10:34:08+00:00September 21st, 2021|Criminal Defence|

5/5 - (1 vote)

Criminal Lawyers Association
Toronnto Lawyers Association
Law Society of Ontario
Criminal Lawyers Association
Toronnto Lawyers Association
Law Society of Ontario
Excellent4.9 Based on 99 reviews fromDaniel SlobodkinDaniel Slobodkin ★★★★★ I have known Mr. Vilkhov in a professional and personal capacity for several years. Mr. Vilkhov is a well-respected and devoted criminal lawyer who prioritizes the success and livelihood of his clients. Mr. Vilkhov goes out of his way and makes time, at all times of day, to tend to the needs of his clients. Mr. Vilkhov is a diligent lawyer I would recommend to anyone dealing with a criminal matter. Well-spoken, confident, methodical and professional are qualities that only begin to scratch the surface of Mr. Vilkhov criminal law practice and his character at whole.Amina HuseynovaAmina Huseynova ★★★★★ I've known Igor professionally for a long time, one of the most dedicated criminal lawyers I have met. He gets amazing results for his clients and I would recommend anyone who is looking to hire him.maddy mmaddy m ★★★★★ I am international student in Canada, six months ago I was falsely accused of SA and I was charged. I had never dealt with all this in my life and I started looking for a lawyer. I spoke too more than 50 lawyers all over ontario and every lawyer I spoke to tried to scare me and told me that I am a dead meat here and this thing is definitely going to trial and were only interested in talking about their fees. Mr Vilkhov patiently heard my case and told me that there is a high possibility of getting the case withdrawn . He was straightforward and honest. He convinced me after one call that he is the right lawyer for me to retain. He charged a very reasonable fee which he let me pay in installments. He kept me well informed about my case in every stage. Mr. Vilkhov and Daniel from his team were my constant support. Every message and every phone call was answered.Mr Vilkhov got the charges withdrawn!!! My case was in a jurisdictions were cases like these never get withdrawn. But Mr. Vilkhov gave his best and got the charges withdrawn without any conditions. I cannot thank Vilkhov law professional for giving my life back! Mr. Vilkhov is very knowledgeable and he is the lawyer you need by your side when you need it the most! He wins when you need it the most! Thank you Vilkhov law corporation!Jay ModiJay Modi ★★★★★ Igor and his team exceeded my expectations, efficiently getting all charges dropped in my case. His timely responses, coupled with Daniel's eloquence, made for an exceptional first-time experience with a lawyer. They provided a unique blend of empathy and straightforwardness that instilled confidence throughout the legal process. Highly recommendable for anyone in need of a criminal justice lawyer.Naqib PopalNaqib Popal ★★★★★ I just left Brampton courthouse. I was acquitted of 11 charges after a long trial. Igor Vilkhov absolutely killed it during the entire trial. If it wasn’t for him, I would be going to jail. Thank you so much for your work, you ensured the truth came out. Thank you, you got me my life back.Chad AllanChad Allan ★★★★★ Igor got me an amazing deal, he was always communicating with me and updating me about my case, he got me the deal of a lifetime and I can’t him enough. If you are reading this and you are thinking about who to hire, just call him, he is the right lawyer for you.Jamie LewisJamie Lewis ★★★★★ If you need a lawyer who is actually going to work for you, and get results go with Igor at Vilkhov Law. He was very patient and understanding and knows his stuff. I was facing a huge fine which would have devastated me financially for years to come, but with his passionate submission to crown on my behalf he was able to get the fine reduced by 90%. His colleagues he works with are amazing too. Thank you so much for all of your help through this matter Igor! You truely have saved my future. I appreciate it beyond measure! All the best in the future!Akash TyagiAkash Tyagi ★★★★★ Hi all, When i just came to Canada, i got charged with SA, which was a nightmare for me where my so called friends left my side. Then by luck i got to know Mr. Igor and that day changed everything.Being new in a country could cost me a lot but with Igor’s genuine efforts to help me, saved my life.A big thanks to him and god bless him.Must recommended lawyer.Thanks a ton Igor.❤️ted ferreirated ferreira ★★★★★ I met Igor approximately two years ago when we met with him regarding SA charges against our son. Over that time Igor was always there to answer questions that we had, he was reassuring explaining that we had a strong case.From the beginning we were impressed with Igor's demeanor, he was always calm and to the point, he did his best to keep us on track with the facts.Thanks to Igor's thorough preparation he was able to get the SA charges stayed. I cannot tell you how incredible that feeling was.We owe so much to him.We highly recommend Igor to anyone needing Legal help, he will work tirelessly on your behalf.OKOLI MARKOKOLI MARK ★★★★★ Thank you Igor Vilkhov for helping me go through my legal case from the very beginning to the end. Igor's professional advice and approach to difficult legal matter is excellent and recommended, Case has been withdrawn from court!! 1 million thanks for the support throughout this process 🙏.Laura BeniaLaura Benia ★★★★★ Professional, honest and caring.Zafreenp PZafreenp P ★★★★★ Igor and his staff were amazing. They were quick and very assertive. Highly recommend them.Best OgunpoluBest Ogunpolu ★★★★★ He gave me great service very very great service. He caught my case with John gave me great advice. He was always there for me. Always answer my call and returned back. My call when it was messed. I recommend him he’s a very great lawyer knows what he’s doing.Gnrl_AnesthesiaGnrl_Anesthesia ★★★★★ I cannot express enough gratitude for the exceptional legal support I received from Igor, an extraordinary criminal lawyer who helped me overcome the toughest challenge of my life. His unwavering dedication, profound expertise, and genuine compassion gave me a new lease on life, allowing me to rediscover happiness after a harrowing ordeal.Just a few months ago, my world was turned upside down when I found myself entangled in a web of false accusations. Suddenly, I was thrust into a nightmarish scenario, stripped of my peace, and faced with the daunting reality of three criminal charges looming over me. My life, once filled with joy and contentment, had been shattered.In my darkest hour, I sought solace and hope in the form of legal representation, which is when I was introduced to Igor. From our very first meeting, I was immediately struck by his professionalism, empathy, and genuine concern for my well-being. He attentively listened to my side of the story, displaying not only a deep understanding of the complexities of my situation but also an unwavering belief in my innocence.Throughout the entire legal process, Igor's expertise shone brilliantly. His knowledge of the law, combined with his sharp analytical skills, allowed him to navigate the intricate labyrinth of the courtroom with finesse and precision. He meticulously examined every piece of evidence, leaving no stone unturned, in order to construct a compelling defense strategy that would effectively dismantle the false allegations stacked against me.But it was not just Igor's exceptional legal acumen that stood out. What truly set him apart was his genuine care for his clients. He recognized the toll that this unjust situation had taken on my emotional well-being and went above and beyond to provide unwavering support, acting as a pillar of strength during my moments of doubt and despair. His compassion and empathy never wavered, ensuring that I felt heard, valued, and empowered throughout the entire process.Thanks to Igor's unwavering dedication, unyielding pursuit of justice, and his innate ability to dismantle falsehoods, all three criminal charges against me were dismissed. The weight of false accusations that had burdened my spirit for far