Understanding Canadian Child Pornography Possession Laws and the Penalties for a Conviction

The prevalence of child pornography in Canada is evidenced by frequent media reporting of police arresting suspects for related offences. Last month, Toronto Police arrested a city paramedic for possessing and accessing child pornography. At about the same time, Peel Regional Police charged a Mississauga camp counsellor with numerous sexual assault and child pornography charges.

Late last year, Ontario Provincial Police arrested 107 people on over 400 child pornography possession and related charges after a month-long investigation. Among those arrested was a Northern Ontario man police say was planning to kidnap and abuse young children.

Those arrested in this operation account for almost 50% of total 2022 provincial arrests for possessing and/or accessing child pornography, according to Statistics Canada’s “Incident-based crime statistics by detailed violations.” Stat Can data also shows that 191 people were arrested in Ontario for child pornography possession in 2022, accounting for almost 50% of the year’s national arrest total for the charge. Ontario Police also charged 115 people that year with making and distributing child pornography.

Child Pornography as Defined by Canada’s Criminal Code

Section 163.1 of Canada’s Criminal Code broadly defines child pornography to include photographs, film, video, or “other visual representation, whether or not it was made by electronic or mechanical means.” Such imagery constitutes “child” pornography if it:

  • “Shows a person who is or is depicted as being under the age of eighteen years and is engaged in or is depicted as engaged in explicit sexual activity.”
  • Has a “dominant characteristic of which is the depiction, for a sexual purpose, of a sexual organ or the anal region of a person under the age of eighteen years.”

Furthermore, the definition covers:

  • “Any written material, visual representation or audio recording that advocates or counsels sexual activity with a person under the age of eighteen years that would be an offence under this Act.”
  • “Any written material whose dominant characteristic is the description, for a sexual purpose, of sexual activity with a person under the age of eighteen years that would be an offence under this Act.”
  • “Any audio recording that has as its dominant characteristic the description, presentation or representation, for a sexual purpose, of sexual activity with a person under the age of eighteen years that would be an offence under this Act.”

In considering the Code’s broad definition, note first its inclusion of “other visual representation, as well as the three points covering written materials and audio recordings.” As written, this can incorporate drawings, cartoons, other visual artwork, stories, books, other written works, and assorted audio recordings.

In addition, Canadian law enforcement agencies have charged people for possessing art-based, written, and audio renditions of alleged child porn. However, the Code’s language on these points can conflict with the issue of artistic freedom of expression as provided under Section 2 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Supreme Court of Canada Weighs In

Canada’s Supreme Court strived to balance societal interest in combatting child pornography with the Charter’s freedom of expression right in R v Sharpe [2001] SCC 2. In its decision, the high court exempted specific materials from the Code’s child pornography definition based on their limited risk of harming children. These exemptions exclude:

  • “[D]eeply private expressions” depicted in writing or visually that were solely created and held by the accused and made exclusively for their own personal use.”
  • “Private visual recordings of sexual activity created or depicting the accused that do not depict unlawful sexual activity and is held exclusively for the accused’s private use.”

However, in its 2001 decision, the court also ruled that child pornography can include depictions of fictional people, ensuring that art-based child pornography remains illegal.

To further enhance the protection of children in Canada’s child pornography laws, the Supreme Court, in 2015’s R v Barabash [2015] SCC 29 case, held that any exemptions to the law were only valid if no factual exploitation or abuse of children was involved in creating the materials.

Lawful Search and Seizure of Child Pornography Materials

Section 164.1 of the Criminal Code expressly details the search and seizure of child pornography materials. Under this section, a judge may issue a warrant authorizing the seizure of visual, written, or audio materials if “satisfied by information on oath that there are reasonable grounds to believe” it constitutes child pornography.

Section 164.1 (1) contains the same provisions in relation to alleged child pornography stored or made available through a computer system. It also gives the judge the authority to order the removal of the materials from the computer system and order computer system operators to identify persons responsible for posting or storing the materials.

Absent a warrant, the right to search for child porn (or other evidence relating to a crime) on your cell phone or other computerized device is limited due to a Supreme Court ruling in R v Fearon [2014] SCC 77. This ruling held that a warrantless search must be directly connected to the reasons for a suspect’s arrest, and serve a valid law enforcement purpose, such as protecting public safety or preserving evidence.

Penalties for Possessing Child Pornography in Canada

The minimum penalty for possessing child pornography charges in Canada is six months’ imprisonment if charged as a summary conviction offence, which carries a maximum two-year sentence. When charged with an indictable offence, conviction carries a minimum sentence of one year and a maximum prison term of 10 years.

Accessing child pornography has the same penalties, while making or distributing child pornography is solely an indictable offence that carries a respective one-year minimum and 14-year maximum prison sentence. The sole aggravating factor named by the Criminal Code in considering sentencing is whether or not the defendant committed the offence with the intent to make a profit.

Longer-Term Repercussions of a Child Porn Conviction

As with most other sexual offences, the penalties for conviction go beyond imprisonment to include life-long impacts. These impacts include:

  • Inclusion on the National Sex Offender Registry, with mandatory compliance and reporting terms.
  • Mandatory submission of a DNA sample to the national DNA databank.
  • Firearms/weapons prohibitions.
  • Prohibitions on visiting places where those under age 16 may be present.

Defending Against Child Pornography Charges

If you’re facing possession of child pornography possession or related charges, it’s important to seek out the services of an experienced criminal defence lawyer. Given the complexities of the law and the severe penalties that come with a conviction, you cannot afford to defend yourself against such charges on your own.

At Vilkhov Law, we understand the severity of these types of charges, and the need to have access to the services of a lawyer you can trust. Reach out to a member of our team today to schedule your consultation.

By |2023-09-14T13:53:53+00:00September 14th, 2023|Child Pornography Charges|

Rate this post

Criminal Lawyers Association
Toronnto Lawyers Association
Law Society of Ontario
Criminal Lawyers Association
Toronnto Lawyers Association
Law Society of Ontario
Excellent4.9 Based on 99 reviews fromDaniel SlobodkinDaniel Slobodkin ★★★★★ I have known Mr. Vilkhov in a professional and personal capacity for several years. Mr. Vilkhov is a well-respected and devoted criminal lawyer who prioritizes the success and livelihood of his clients. Mr. Vilkhov goes out of his way and makes time, at all times of day, to tend to the needs of his clients. Mr. Vilkhov is a diligent lawyer I would recommend to anyone dealing with a criminal matter. Well-spoken, confident, methodical and professional are qualities that only begin to scratch the surface of Mr. Vilkhov criminal law practice and his character at whole.Amina HuseynovaAmina Huseynova ★★★★★ I've known Igor professionally for a long time, one of the most dedicated criminal lawyers I have met. He gets amazing results for his clients and I would recommend anyone who is looking to hire him.maddy mmaddy m ★★★★★ I am international student in Canada, six months ago I was falsely accused of SA and I was charged. I had never dealt with all this in my life and I started looking for a lawyer. I spoke too more than 50 lawyers all over ontario and every lawyer I spoke to tried to scare me and told me that I am a dead meat here and this thing is definitely going to trial and were only interested in talking about their fees. Mr Vilkhov patiently heard my case and told me that there is a high possibility of getting the case withdrawn . He was straightforward and honest. He convinced me after one call that he is the right lawyer for me to retain. He charged a very reasonable fee which he let me pay in installments. He kept me well informed about my case in every stage. Mr. Vilkhov and Daniel from his team were my constant support. Every message and every phone call was answered.Mr Vilkhov got the charges withdrawn!!! My case was in a jurisdictions were cases like these never get withdrawn. But Mr. Vilkhov gave his best and got the charges withdrawn without any conditions. I cannot thank Vilkhov law professional for giving my life back! Mr. Vilkhov is very knowledgeable and he is the lawyer you need by your side when you need it the most! He wins when you need it the most! Thank you Vilkhov law corporation!Jay ModiJay Modi ★★★★★ Igor and his team exceeded my expectations, efficiently getting all charges dropped in my case. His timely responses, coupled with Daniel's eloquence, made for an exceptional first-time experience with a lawyer. They provided a unique blend of empathy and straightforwardness that instilled confidence throughout the legal process. Highly recommendable for anyone in need of a criminal justice lawyer.Naqib PopalNaqib Popal ★★★★★ I just left Brampton courthouse. I was acquitted of 11 charges after a long trial. Igor Vilkhov absolutely killed it during the entire trial. If it wasn’t for him, I would be going to jail. Thank you so much for your work, you ensured the truth came out. Thank you, you got me my life back.Chad AllanChad Allan ★★★★★ Igor got me an amazing deal, he was always communicating with me and updating me about my case, he got me the deal of a lifetime and I can’t him enough. If you are reading this and you are thinking about who to hire, just call him, he is the right lawyer for you.Jamie LewisJamie Lewis ★★★★★ If you need a lawyer who is actually going to work for you, and get results go with Igor at Vilkhov Law. He was very patient and understanding and knows his stuff. I was facing a huge fine which would have devastated me financially for years to come, but with his passionate submission to crown on my behalf he was able to get the fine reduced by 90%. His colleagues he works with are amazing too. Thank you so much for all of your help through this matter Igor! You truely have saved my future. I appreciate it beyond measure! All the best in the future!Akash TyagiAkash Tyagi ★★★★★ Hi all, When i just came to Canada, i got charged with SA, which was a nightmare for me where my so called friends left my side. Then by luck i got to know Mr. Igor and that day changed everything.Being new in a country could cost me a lot but with Igor’s genuine efforts to help me, saved my life.A big thanks to him and god bless him.Must recommended lawyer.Thanks a ton Igor.❤️ted ferreirated ferreira ★★★★★ I met Igor approximately two years ago when we met with him regarding SA charges against our son. Over that time Igor was always there to answer questions that we had, he was reassuring explaining that we had a strong case.From the beginning we were impressed with Igor's demeanor, he was always calm and to the point, he did his best to keep us on track with the facts.Thanks to Igor's thorough preparation he was able to get the SA charges stayed. I cannot tell you how incredible that feeling was.We owe so much to him.We highly recommend Igor to anyone needing Legal help, he will work tirelessly on your behalf.OKOLI MARKOKOLI MARK ★★★★★ Thank you Igor Vilkhov for helping me go through my legal case from the very beginning to the end. Igor's professional advice and approach to difficult legal matter is excellent and recommended, Case has been withdrawn from court!! 1 million thanks for the support throughout this process 🙏.Laura BeniaLaura Benia ★★★★★ Professional, honest and caring.