Limitations of Using Affidavits
iStock
  1. The Role of Affidavits in Legal Proceedings
  2. Credibility Issues
  3. Conflicting Testimonies
  4. Prosecutors and Judge Discretion
  5. Practical Limitations and Legal Outcomes
  6. Navigating Challenges with Affidavits

Affidavits in criminal justice are commonly used by complainants wishing to have the charges against another person dropped in cases like domestic violence, uttering threats, and similar criminal situations involving mandatory charging. Viewed as a solution to cases where the police are under obligation to lay the charges irrespective of the victim’s intention to proceed, affidavits can be an effective legal tool to help get criminal accusations dropped.

At the same time, dropping the charges with affidavits can be complicated in the presence of conflicting earlier testimonies and may expose the complainant to the risks of facing criminal penalties for false statements. Below we discuss the role and limitations of using affidavits, the importance of legal counsel in affidavit preparation, and outline practical steps for navigating challenges in using affidavits to drop charges.

The Role of Affidavits in Legal Proceedings

In Canadian criminal law, an affidavit is a statement made under oath by one of the parties — usually the complainant. Unlike the US, which has an affidavit of non-prosecution, there is only one type of affidavit in Ontario, which is a statement used to provide new evidence in the case. Affidavits add to the total body of evidence, while their admissibility is evaluated by the court.

When complainants seek dropping the charges with affidavits, it is important to know that simply stating that they are no longer interested in pressing the charges has no weight in the courtroom. Instead, the complainants need to present new facts and provide the Crown Attorneys with persuasive reasons why they might want to reassess their case.

Credibility Issues

In Canada, the weight of an affidavit in court as a piece of evidence can depend on the credibility of the person who is making it, known as the affiant. Specifically, under the Canada Evidence Act, the prosecution may question the affiant or any witnesses on whether they have been convicted of prior offences to assess their credibility.

Accordingly, the prosecution will consider the affiant’s previous criminal record when assessing the veracity of their statements in the affidavit. The legal credibility of affidavits can be further undermined by conflicting testimonies, for example, discrepancies between the affidavit and previous reports made to the police.

Conflicting Testimonies

When the complainant makes an affidavit, there is often a risk of contradicting their previous testimonies and other evidence. For example, when complainant tries to recant their previous version of events in an affidavit, their statements can come into conflict with their previous statements under oath, domestic violence questionnaires, the audio recording of the 911 call and other similar evidence.

In these situations, the complainant often faces serious risks resulting from conflicting testimonies. For example, making false statements or lying in an affidavit can potentially result in charges of perjury. In another scenario, acknowledging that previous statements under oath to the police were false can result in criminal charges for public mischief.

Prosecutors and Judge Discretion

According to the Crown Prosecution Manual, prosecutors exercise “a broad discretion to conduct cases in a way that ensures justice is done and is responsive to the particular circumstances of the case.” This fully applies to affidavits, including how they are viewed by the Crown Attorneys and the judge and their effectiveness in having the charges dropped.

As a statement of facts, an affidavit cannot prevent the prosecution from proceeding with the case, even if the complainant does not want another person to be charged. In the best-case scenario, an affidavit can help to convince prosecutors to reassess the case from the complainant’s perspective, clarify the relationship with the accused and provide reasons why a conviction may not serve the public interest.

Practical Limitations and Legal Outcomes

While a properly made affidavit can be a powerful tool for having criminal charges dropped, its ability to do so is limited when the affiant’s credibility is compromised. However, the main reasons why affidavits fall short are conflicting testimonies and contradictions with other evidence present in the case, for example, photos of injuries, footage from a body-worn camera on a police officer or a police report.

When the Crown considers a complainant’s affidavit, the prosecution prioritizes public interest in securing a conviction under the circumstances over the complainant’s intent to have charges dropped. For this reason, an effective affidavit needs to strike a balance between the pursuit of justice and the complainant’s interest to have the accused cleared of charges.

Navigating Challenges with Affidavits

While forms for affidavits are readily available online, a well-drafted statement under oath requires much more than filling in the blanks. For an affidavit to achieve its goal of having criminal charges dropped, it must be carefully drafted according to legal standards for affidavits in Canada within a broader context of all the evidence available in the case.

First, when drafting an affidavit, the affiant should be cognizant of the risks of criminal prosecution for making false statements or contradicting previous testimony or other evidence. Second, an affidavit must be professionally written to stand up to legal requirements and provide additional evidence on what happened before the police arrived. In practice, drafting such an affidavit is hardly achievable without the assistance of an experienced lawyer.

Conclusion

Affidavits are complex legal instruments, and their effect on the criminal case depends on the statements they contain and other evidence available to the prosecution. Meanwhile, it is worth noting that dropping charges with affidavits is not guaranteed for any type of offence — from domestic violence to assault with a weapon under the Criminal Code. Last but not least, making conflicting testimony under oath can expose the complainant to the risk of facing criminal charges for false statements.

While it is absolutely possible to have an affidavit filled in using a form available online and have it certified by a notary, such an approach rarely achieves the goal of having the charges dropped. Instead, contacting experienced criminal defence lawyers in Toronto to address affidavit challenges offers the best chances of obtaining the most favourable outcome under the circumstances.

By |2024-09-24T13:29:36+00:00September 24th, 2024|Criminal Defence, Uncategorized|

5/5 - (1 vote)

Criminal Lawyers Association
Toronnto Lawyers Association
Law Society of Ontario
Criminal Lawyers Association
Toronnto Lawyers Association
Law Society of Ontario
Excellent5.0 Based on 141 reviews fromDennis ParkDennis Park ★★★★★ Igor is an absolute fantastic lawyer and I would highly recommend. I was facing some serious charges and Igor not only got all my charges withdrawn, he was very caring and informative through out the whole process. I owe him very dearly for getting me a second chance at life.Jodi HixonJodi Hixon ★★★★★ My name is Gary Hixon I've had Igor as my lawyer, and he did nothing but worked on my case and he got me worried at first , but because of COVID the first time I actually met him was when he hit my case out of the ball park. He's a great man I recommend him too all. Thank you Igor.Big DOWNEYYYBig DOWNEYYY ★★★★★ Greatness!!!! Mr.Igor Vilkhov and his team did a tremendous job on my stabbing case! He saved my life today I was facing years in the penitentiary for assault and he literally got it reduced to 2 years house arrest. He was an absolute pleasure to work with has a great attitude & I highly recommend him to everyone looking for a defense lawyer. He is definitely one of the TOP LAWYERS in Toronto! Thank you so muchTristan SmithTristan Smith ★★★★★ Igor has been a tremendous help and has saved my life, not just metaphorically. I can't think of a better and more competent person (and team) to have behind you! I just walked out of the courthouse acquitted after trial. I was facing five years in jail. Thank you so much.Zabi AkbariZabi Akbari ★★★★★ Mr. Vilkhov represented me in a trial today and I was found not guilty. I am a professional and this caused a lot of emotional turmoil for me. Igor was amazing during the trial, he absolutely nailed it. Thank you for getting my life back.MARK SINGHMARK SINGH ★★★★★ Igor Vilkov, was the calm in a storm that I thought would never pass. Mr Vilkov always made sure to answer all my questions a concerns . When incarcerated Mr Vilkov always kept in touch with my family . Without his expertise I would have never received such a favourable sentence . He was able to get me a non costodaial sentence for 3 serious charges that could have had me locked up for 2 years or more . Mr Vilkov truly cares about his client's a there family and not just about fees . I would recommend Mr Vilkov to anyone who has been charged he is a true professional.Thompson RanjitsinghThompson Ranjitsingh ★★★★★ Very great SA lawyer very reliable .he will do a very good job in getting you acquitted. Thanks a million igorJoshua RJoshua R ★★★★★ Best lawyer out there thank you for fighting my caseLydia RanjitsinghLydia Ranjitsingh ★★★★★ He's a very good lawyers, he got my son charges drop.Thank youthompson “Aaliyah R.” ranjitsinghthompson “Aaliyah R.” ranjitsingh ★★★★★ KK ★★★★★ So thankful that he got the job done and with reasonable pricing, he was so helpful and respectful throughout the whole process. 5 stars well earned.Sami Life Style (SamSam)Sami Life Style (SamSam) ★★★★★ I was facing very serious charges and was represented by Mr. Prajs. Mr. Prajs and the whole team at Vilkhov law vigorously defended me at trial and my charges were withdrawn. I can recommend Mr. Prajs and the whole Vilkhov team to anyone facing serious allegations.Ysabel AtienzaYsabel Atienza ★★★★★ Igor displays a level of professionalism, knowledge and dedication that puts his clients at ease during a very stressful time. His expertise in criminal law is unparalleled. What sets him apart is his unwavering commitment to his clients. He genuinely cares about his clients’ well-being and will go above and beyond for you!Kevin DKevin D ★★★★★ Igor is a great lawyer and has provided valuable guidance throughout my experience with him. He has always been honest and straightforward which I appreciate very much. I would recommend him to anyone looking for a successful outcome.Narmatha SNarmatha S ★★★★★ Igor is a dedicated and intelligent lawyer, known for his commitment to his clients.I've witnessed firsthand his incredible work ethic and professionalism, which sets a high standard in the legal field. His ability to meticulously research cases and articulate arguments convincingly is truly impressive!Fred BalmerFred Balmer ★★★★★ Experience with Vilkhov Law was great, Igor made all my charges get dropped without any issues. I would highly recommend this firm to everyoneDavinder GillDavinder Gill ★★★★★ Ecem KokEcem Kok ★★★★★ My experience with Vilkhov Law was nothing short of exceptional. Facing a daunting legal battle, looking at significant jail time and scared, I sought Igor Vilkhov's expertise based on his stellar reputation in criminal law. From the initial consultation to the trial, every step was handled with precision and care. His deep knowledge of the law and strategic approach gave me confidence throughout.In a pivotal moment during my case, Igor Vilkhov's dedication and expertise truly shone through, resulting in a favorable outcome that exceeded my expectations. His communication was clear and timely, keeping me informed and reassured at every turn.I am immensely grateful to Igor Vilkhov and the entire team at Vilkhov Law for his unwavering support and tireless effort. His professionalism and commitment are second to none. If you find yourself in need of expert legal representation, look no further than Vilkhov Law. He is simply the best.Rhea OXXORhea OXXO ★★★★★ Jessie TeixeiraJessie Teixeira ★★★★★ I would like to thank Igor Vilkhov and his dedicated team for their professional assistance in dealing with my matter. I could not be happier about the way my matter was handled and am very satisfied with the result.Annabella FusaroAnnabella Fusaro ★★★★★ Igor Vilkhov was an amazing Lawyer. I met him through one of his colleagues and one thing I can say he fights for your rights and he doesn’t amazing job. He was so patient and kind with me. I’m very grateful for the outcome of my case. May god bless Igor And the amazing work he does.AnnabellaXuan LinXuan Lin ★★★★★ Hello my name is Leon I got charged with SA in 2021 in relation to a young complainant. I have been looking about 10 lawyer all of then is bad and lie all they care is money never help my case .Until I meet Igor I told him what happened he told me no worry he will try his best for help me . And this year May I won the case I just can't believe it Igor is best lawyer he is legendary . Guy you should believe in Igor he is really good. His preparation was meticulous and was acquitted. He saved my life.ChrisChris ★★★★★ The Best Lawyer In my opinion. A legal Tactician in the modern day criminal justice court systems. Very professional service. Great Techniques and Extremely knowledgable and Highly talented and recommended team.I’m 37 old Newfoundlander who is not well spoken but this was an easy to write.Nikolai Wheeler-BalazevNikolai Wheeler-Balazev ★★★★★ I want to start off this review by thanking Mr.Vilkhov for handling my case, Igor got my case resolved in a timely manor, i had previously been going to court for my case for about a year, and when i had gotten Mr.Vilkhov as my lawyer he had my case resolved and all my charges withdrawn in a matter of days. If anybody is looking for a lawyer i would urge you to go with Mr.Vilkhov, he knows what he is doing and knows how to do it quickly.Shannan HarrisonShannan Harrison ★★★★★ Mr. Vilkhov is an outstanding lawyer, I just avoided a lengthy jail sentence because of him. I literally cannot believe what he was able to do for me. The judge in court praised him for his work, thank you so much.js_loader

CONTACT US

“Caring, honest, and highly knowledgeable.”

Contact Igor for a Free Consultation!

Please contact us online for a free consultation.
Go to Top