In the summer of 2020, you may have seen a petition circulating social media urging the Crown to appeal two related cases that were heard at the Ontario Court of Appeal: R. v. Sullivan and R. v. Chan. The issue pinpointed by this petition and the attention surrounding these cases seemed to be that they would make it easier for perpetrators of sexual assault to be acquitted thus further marginalizing survivors of sexual assault. It is understandable that the offence of sexual assault brings out strong emotions in people. Sexual assault is a harrowing and life-altering experience. That being said, the subsequent attention and critique these cases attracted misunderstands the state of the law.

While the circumstances of Sullivan and Chan were tragic, neither of them dealt with sexual assault. In Sullivan, Mr. Sullivan ingested multiple doses of a drug in a suicide attempt. This drug caused psychosis, and he stabbed his mother repeatedly—believing her to be an alien. In Chan, Mr. Chan ingested “magic mushrooms.” He began experiencing hallucinations, including believing that he was God. He broke into his father’s house, stabbing his father several times as well as injuring his father’s partner. Both Mr. Sullivan and Mr. Chan experienced extreme intoxication.

The main issue in these appeals hinged on the constitutionality of section 33.1 of the Criminal Code. Section 33.1 essentially states that an accused cannot use the defence that they were so intoxicated that they lacked the general intent or voluntariness to commit the offence, if that intoxication was self-induced. Criminal offences either involve general intent or specific intent. General intent offences, like assault or even sexual assault, require very minimal mental acuity; usually the fact that you committed the offence is enough to prove the mental element. The thinking behind section 33.1 is that if these offences have such a low threshold when it comes to their mental element, then whether an accused is intoxicated is irrelevant. What the Court of Appeal said in Sullivan and Chan is that when it comes to extreme intoxication, that level of intoxication not irrelevant. In fact, the Court struck down section 33.1, ruling that an accused could now used this defence. The backlash began.

The backlash to the defence, however, is not new. In 1994, the Supreme Court released its judgment in R. v. Daviault. In Daviault, the accused had consumed seven to eight bottles of beer and almost an entire 40-ounce bottle of brandy. He was accused of sexually assaulting the complainant, although he had no recollection of that. A pharmacologist testified that someone at that level of intoxication could experience a blackout and lose touch with reality. The Supreme Court found that extreme intoxication, even when self-induced, can be a used as a defence. It dubbed such extreme intoxication as being “akin to automatism.” The Court noted that while it is an available defence, it is not a defence that can normally be successfully mounted.

There was a similar critique in response to Daviault as there is now to Sullivan and Chan. At that time, Parliament enacted section 33.1 to preclude accused persons from relying on Daviault and the extreme intoxication defence. Sixteen years later, Sullivan and Chan basically reiterated the arguments in Daviault. Not only do the arguments still seem pertinent, the link of this defence to sexual assault through Daviault seems to still be fresh in people’s minds.

Yet it is important to understand the reasoning behind these decisions. We have to understand the fundamental principles of criminal law and justice. One of the most fundamental principles underlying Daviault, Chan, and Sullivan—and criminal law in general—is the principle of voluntariness. It is said that criminal law sanctions actions that an individual does voluntarily. The concept of voluntariness is behind every offence, and it must be demonstrated. But what if the accused does not have awareness and control over their actions? What if they have no concept of what has occurred? Section 33.1 allows an accused to be convicted for involuntary acts (acts that cannot be said to truly be their own), which violates their Charter right to life, liberty, and security of the person and their guarantee of the presumption of innocence. Furthermore, it is the Crown’s duty to prove all requisite elements of an offence beyond a reasonable doubt; section 33.1 allows them to circumvent this requirement.

No matter how ostensibly heinous an offence is or how unsympathetic or unsavoury an accused person is, we cannot pick and choose how fundamental principles are applied and who is afforded these protections. If we did that, our rights would become meaningless. The Crown would then become our judge and jury. It is doubtful that anyone would want to live in such a state of affairs.

Sullivan and Chan and the critiques that follow them present a good time to reflect on the principles of criminal law and how the justice system functions. We must understand and appreciate these principles. We must understand that extreme intoxication is not a catch-all defence. It is not an easy thing to prove in the slightest, and it cannot be emphasized enough that this defence is reserved for the rarest of cases. But our justice system is better for having rulings like Sullivan and Chan.

By |2023-08-11T10:34:18+00:00December 21st, 2020|Sexual Assault|

5/5 - (2 votes)

Criminal Lawyers Association
Toronnto Lawyers Association
Law Society of Ontario
Criminal Lawyers Association
Toronnto Lawyers Association
Law Society of Ontario
Excellent5.0 Based on 119 reviews fromAnoop RAnoop R ★★★★★ One of the best law firms in town! Highly recommended.ARRARR ★★★★★ I was falsely accused and charged with a serious offence. All it took was just one phone call from the complainant. As an immigrant, it was a nightmare. Fortunately Igor was the first person whom I contacted and I knew he was the one and I retained him. Beware of the lawyers who try to scare you, make you feel insecure. From the first phone call, he never made me feel insecure. He was confident that he can get the work done. Igor and Daniel promptly attended all my court dates. It took a while to achieve the resolution and finally my case was unconditionally withdrawn. I can't thank him enough. As Igor is a busy person, I was getting updates regularly from Daniel. I would give six stars to Daniel. Igor should never let him go. I would definitely recommend this law firm. You might sometimes feel that Igor is late in responding, but he'll be putting all his efforts behind the scene. Just have faith in him. I wish Igor and Daniel all the best.Maria AgasMaria Agas ★★★★★ I was very impressed with his professionalism, swift responses and attention to detail. He was proactive and always communicated next steps. I’m so happy we came across Igor and his team. Igor is amazing and wonderful lawyer.Cindy LiCindy Li ★★★★★ I cannot express my gratitude enough for the exceptional legal representation provided by Igor. Facing wrongful accusations was a harrowing experience, but Igor's expertise and dedication swiftly turned the tide in my favor. He navigated the complexities of the case with professionalism, demonstrating remarkable intelligence and a deep understanding of the legal system. Thanks to his efforts, the charges were withdrawn in a timely manner, allowing me to move forward with my life. Igor is not just a good lawyer; he is an outstanding advocate for his clients. I wholeheartedly recommend his services to anyone in need of top-notch legal assistance.George ArellanoGeorge Arellano ★★★★★ Mr. Vilkhov got my charges withdrawn today after a very stressful time in my life. I hired him because of his reviews and I am not surprised that I got this result. I appreciate him and his team. Igor literally dedicates his entire life for his clients.Latch RamoutarLatch Ramoutar ★★★★★ I am sitting here at 10 Armoury street after my charges were just withdrawn. I cannot thank Igor enough for what he has done for me. This was supposed to be a trial where I was facing a ten year jail sentence. Somehow Igor got my charges dropped. This man is the lawyer you need, hands down. Also a very nice person.Emad MEmad M ★★★★★ Do not blink! Go with him.I know for stressful this process might be an how awful law system might be treating you, also how difficult it might be to trust someone with your “life”.Igor knows what he is doing and he saved my partner and I from false accusations of a jealous individual!He didn’t over charge, he didn’t hold back on any help a lawyer could possibly provide.This man is the best saviour one can ask for in these situations.Christa DuchenoChrista Ducheno ★★★★★ No kidding, if you need an attorney and You want the Best lawyer to defend you and your rights in the legal system I’d definitely recommend you call Igor Vilkhov.I am completely and gratefully satisfied with His professional guidance, knowledge of the complex legal system and most of all for saving my life. I give Igor and his Team my hands heart shout out Thank You for your dedication, I couldn’t have gotten through it without Y’all.Stephanie SchembriStephanie Schembri ★★★★★ Mr.Vilkhov thank you for keeping our family together we are forever gratefulAndreyAndrey ★★★★★ Highly recommend. Fast and reasonableRajveer SinghRajveer Singh ★★★★★ WaheguruAlyssa TolentinoAlyssa Tolentino ★★★★★ Igor is an incredibly professional, yet empathetic lawyer — I retained his services for charges laid against someone close to me, and would make that decision time and time again! He pays attention to every detail, and will be by your side to get the best outcome possible. You’re in good hands with him.Kathryn GilfoyKathryn Gilfoy ★★★★★ john la magnajohn la magna ★★★★★ I had a great experience with Vilkhov Law. Igor was professional, efficient, and made my very stressful first endeavour into needing legal council as much of a breeze as it could have been.He was also very patient with me as a first time offender with way too many questions.I highly recommended Igor, and his team at Vilkhov Law!Norbert WysockiNorbert Wysocki ★★★★★ Igor and his team provided excellent service in very delicate and emotional case. They were extremely supporting and knowledgeable. Thank you for everything you have done!Jason WorthJason Worth ★★★★★ Words cannot describe what Igor has done for me. Igor is the most skilled and amazing attorney I have ever met in my entire life. I had a long list of charges (some that carried some serious penitentiary time) and worked some serious magic with countless hours behind the scenes for me to make just 1 appearance and have ALL THE CHARGES WITHDRAWN and a peace bond put in place. The timeframe for it was amazing as well he took care of me and this situation in only 15 months! (we all know the justice system does not work that fast normally!) If you want a very highly skilled, passionate, available(Igor would take calls and messages even after normal hours to fill me in!), experienced and dedicated attorney that will work tirelssly with you and for you to get you the absolute best results then Igor is your man! 5 stars does not do this man justice he deserves 100 stars!N -N - ★★★★★ Great lawyer. Knowledgeable and helpful. 10/10 would recommend :)GLORIS SPENCEGLORIS SPENCE ★★★★★ Working with Igor and his team during a very unpleasant situation has been a blessing. Even though the legal process was a lengthy one, they were there to answer the questions and concerns we had.Thankfully, it's all over and settled and hopefully we'll not need his services again, but it is reassuring to know that if the situation should every arise where legal counsel is needed, Vilkhov Law Professional will be there in my corner.Thank you.Scott K.Scott K. ★★★★★ I would like to give Igor 5 stars for handling my serious case for the last 11 months of my life. In December 2022, I was wrongfully accused of 2 serious charges under my name however, Igor took care of it from the beginning and finally all of those wrongful charges are withdrawn and now I feel much better and at ease. I am very glad that Igor could help me throughout the hard process and bring out the best result possible! Also, what I want to pinpoint out for the most is that he picks up the call by himself and you get to contact directly with him whenever you have questions or want updates throughout the process. I know that it could be tiring for lawyers who have other clients at the moment but Igor always keep a close contact with his client and I was always able to talk to him directly when I needed for the last 11 months. At last, I wish all the best for Igor and hope that god blesses throughout his career and may he be able to offer his professionalism to help other people in need. Thank you Igor :)SAID ALISAID ALI ★★★★★ Igor is an exceptional lawyer! I am very thankful for his excellent professional legal advice and assistance, he was able to drop my S.A charges. Thank you Igor for everything you've done, I really appreciate your services.M AlyM Aly ★★★★★ I was charged with SA, which rarely ever get dropped and generally always go to trial. Igor Vilkhov was able to get my charges fully withdrawn with no consequences or harm to me.Every lawyer I spoke with quoted me astronomical fees and explained how they would have to jump through hoops and perform ‘legal gymnastics’ to help me. Igor was the only lawyer who gave me a fair and realistic fee structure. He walked me through what the process would look like and gave realistic expectations. It was clear from the start he knew what he was doing and that his experience was significant. Throughout the process he provided regular updates and was always reachable. If you’re charged, I highly recommend at least speaking with Igor before making a decision on an attorney.Melissa HinrichsenMelissa Hinrichsen ★★★★★ Igor was amazing to deal with. His response time was amazing compared to others. He knew what I needed and got the job done. I highly recommend to everyone.NicoleNicole ★★★★★ Very kind and helpfulDevere SDevere S ★★★★★ Mr.Vilkhov is a professional and very good lawyer, goes through everyrhing to make sure it gets dealt with properly, He replies fast if you have questions or anything as well, along with his staff Jessica she was a big help as well.Jessica Gavrikov-ZinchenkoJessica Gavrikov-Zinchenko ★★★★★ Igor Vilkhov is a one-of-a-kind lawyer, his skills truly exceed expectations. He is incredibly diligent and has a passion for ensuring that his clients receive the best possible representation. Additionally, he has a wonderful team behind him, ensuring that his business operations and client relations are running smoothly.js_loader

CONTACT US

“Caring, honest, and highly knowledgeable.”

Contact Igor for a Free Consultation!

Please contact us online for a free consultation.
Go to Top