Table of Contents:
- What is Sexual Assault?
- Types of Sexual Assault Charges
- Key Elements of the Offence
- What Happens After a Sexual Assault Charge?
- What Happens in a Sexual Assault Trial?
- What are the Penalties for Being Charged with Sexual Assault?
- How to Get Sexual Assault Charges Dismissed in Ontario
- Alternatives to Conviction
- Potential Defences Against Sexual Assault
- The Psychological and Social Impact of a Conviction
- False Allegations and Public Mischief
Why Sexual Assault Charges Matter
Sexual Assault is a serious offence and a conviction will have a devastating impact on your future. The stigma of having a criminal record for any type of sex crime can affect your ability to get a job or housing for years, decades, and even a lifetime. It can also have severe social implications, leading to an increased risk of depression, mental health issues, and suicide. But some people who are charged with sexual assault are innocent, and other times, charges are over-inflated due to a particular bias against sex crimes in certain jurisdictions. Regardless of your situation, it is critical to hire experienced legal counsel immediately if you have been charged with sexual assault in Ontario. A skilled sexual assault lawyer may be able to have your charges reduced, or dropped entirely.
What is Sexual Assault?
Sexual assault in Canada is defined as any non-consensual physical contact of a sexual nature. It includes a broad range of behaviours—from unwanted sexual touching to violent acts involving coercion or force. According to Section 271 of the Criminal Code of Canada, sexual assault occurs when a person intentionally applies force to another person in circumstances of a sexual nature without their consent. The seriousness of the act does not depend solely on physical injury but on the violation of personal autonomy and dignity.
Sexual assault charges may arise even in situations where no weapon was used or no physical injuries occurred. The key legal issue is the absence of consent, which must be voluntary, informed, and ongoing. Even actions like kissing, groping, or pressing against someone in a sexual way can lead to charges if done without the other person’s agreement.
Types of Sexual Assault Charges
In Canada, sexual assault charges are categorized based on the level of violence, the presence of weapons, and whether bodily harm occurred. The Criminal Code recognizes three primary levels of sexual assault:
1. Level 1 – Sexual Assault (Section 271)
This is the most common and least severe type of charge. It involves non-consensual sexual contact without bodily harm, use of a weapon, or threats of significant violence. Examples include unwanted kissing, touching, or groping.
Maximum penalty:
- Summary conviction: Up to 2 years less a day in jail and/or a fine
- Indictable offence: Up to 10 years in prison
2. Level 2 – Sexual Assault with a Weapon, Threats to a Third Party, or Causing Bodily Harm (Section 272)
This level involves aggravating factors such as the use or threat of a weapon, causing bodily harm to the victim, or threatening someone else in the process.
Maximum penalty:
- Up to 14 years in prison
3. Level 3 – Aggravated Sexual Assault (Section 273)
This is the most serious form of sexual assault. It includes incidents where the accused wounds, maims, disfigures, or endangers the life of the victim during the assault.
Maximum penalty:
- Up to life imprisonment
Each level carries mandatory minimum sentences if the victim is under 16 years old.
Key Elements of the Offence
To convict someone of sexual assault in Ontario, the Crown must prove three key elements beyond a reasonable doubt, as outlined in the Criminal Code of Canada:
1. Sexual Contact
There must be intentional physical contact of a sexual nature. Courts assess this based on:
- The nature of the act
- The body part touched
- The context and accompanying words or gestures
2. Lack of Consent
Consent must be voluntary, ongoing, and clearly expressed. Under Section 273.1(2) of the Criminal Code, consent is not valid if:
- It was obtained through force, threats, fraud, or abuse of authority
- The complainant was incapable of consenting (e.g., unconscious, intoxicated, or underage)
- The accused continued after consent was withdrawn
3. Intent and Awareness
The accused must have intended the sexual contact and either knew the complainant did not consent, or was reckless or willfully blind to the lack of consent.
According to Section 273.2, a mistaken belief in consent is not a defence if:
- It resulted from self-induced intoxication
- The accused failed to take reasonable steps to confirm consent
What Happens After a Sexual Assault Charge?
Being charged with sexual assault initiates a complex legal process that can be overwhelming. Understanding what to expect after the charge is critical to protecting your rights and preparing for the steps ahead.
Arrest and Bail
After being charged, you may be arrested and taken into custody. In some cases, the police might release you with a summons or appearance notice to attend court at a later date.
If arrested, you will typically have a bail hearing within 24 hours or at the next available court date. During this hearing, the court decides whether to release you while your case proceeds, often under specific conditions such as:
- Reporting regularly to a bail supervisor
- Avoiding contact with the complainant
- Staying within a certain geographic area
Failing to meet bail conditions can result in re-arrest and detention until trial.
The Court Process Explained
Once released on bail (or if released with a summons), your case will move through the court system. The process generally includes:
- First Appearance: You will appear before a judge who will read the charges and discuss bail conditions if not already decided. You may enter a plea (guilty or not guilty) at this stage.
- Preliminary Hearing (for Indictable Offences): The court determines whether there is sufficient evidence to proceed to trial.
- Trial: The Crown must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. You have the right to present a defence, cross-examine witnesses, and challenge the evidence.
- Sentencing (if convicted): If found guilty, the judge will impose a sentence based on the severity of the offence, your criminal record, and other factors.
Throughout this process, having an experienced criminal defence lawyer is vital to ensure your rights are protected and to navigate the complexities of the legal system.
What Happens in a Sexual Assault Trial?
reasonable doubt that you committed the act in question. The court will consider several factors when deciding if there is enough evidence to proceed with the charges against you, including:
- Did you use force or threaten to use force during the incident?
- Were you or the victim under the influence of drugs or alcohol at the time?
- Are you in a position of authority which could have been used to influence the alleged victim?
What the Crown Must Prove
To secure a conviction, the prosecution must establish these key elements beyond a reasonable doubt:
- That sexual assault actually occurred;
- That the person charged is the one who committed the act;
- That the victim did not give consent or was legally incapable of consenting.
The Crown must show that the contact was sexual and without valid consent, as defined by law (see Section 273 of the Criminal Code).
Evidence and Witness Testimony
The trial will involve the presentation of evidence and witness testimony from both the prosecution and the defence. This may include:
- Statements from the complainant and any witnesses;
- Physical evidence, such as medical reports or forensic analysis;
- Expert testimony regarding consent, trauma, or other relevant issues;
- Cross-examination of witnesses to challenge the credibility or reliability of their statements.
An experienced defence lawyer will carefully examine all evidence, identify inconsistencies or gaps in the prosecution’s case, and build a strong defence strategy to create reasonable doubt.
What are the Penalties for Being Charged with Sexual Assault?
As with all crimes, the penalties for sexual assault depend largely on the type and severity of the assault committed. For minor sexual assault offences, penalties may range from discharge to up to 18 months in jail, whereas an indictable case of simple sexual assault can carry a penalty of up to 10 years in jail. If the crime involved a weapon, serious injuries, or a minor victim, penalties are significantly more serious, including up to 14 years in prison and inclusion on the National Sex Offender Registry for up to 20 years. In some cases, an offender may need to remain on the Registry for a lifetime.
How to Get Sexual Assault Charges Dismissed in Ontario
When the charges against you are for a fairly low-level sexual assault, you may be able to have your charges dropped by signing a peace bond or applying for a discharge. However, this will depend largely on the particulars of your case. In addition to the charges themselves being relatively minor, you should have no prior criminal record or only an older record with minor charges. The Crown will be much less likely to grant a discharge or peace bond if you have recent, multiple, or serious offences on your criminal record.
Role of a Strong Defence
A strong defence is crucial in negotiating the possibility of having sexual assault charges dismissed or reduced. An experienced defence lawyer will thoroughly investigate the circumstances of your case, gather evidence, and identify weaknesses in the prosecution’s case. They may also negotiate with the Crown to explore alternative resolutions such as peace bonds or discharges where appropriate. Your legal counsel can help ensure your rights are protected and work towards the best possible outcome, whether that means dismissal, reduction of charges, or alternative sentencing.
Alternatives to Conviction
Facing sexual assault charges can be overwhelming, but depending on the specifics of your case, there may be alternatives to a criminal conviction and incarceration. These options are designed to offer less severe consequences while still addressing the seriousness of the offence. Understanding these alternatives can help you and your lawyer explore possible outcomes that avoid a traditional conviction and its long-term impacts.
Peace Bond
If a peace bond is offered, the charges against you will be withdrawn when it is signed. If you are given an absolute or conditional discharge, you will still be found guilty, but will avoid jail time, a permanent criminal record, and the need to be listed on the National Sex Offender Registry. While a peace bond is the preferred option, you may be deemed unsuitable due to past criminal history or the severity of your offence.
Absolute or Conditional Discharge
With a conditional discharge, you will remain on probation with certain conditions for a period of time, and the discharge will come off your record after three years. With an absolute discharge, you will be released with no probation or conditions, and the discharge will only remain on your record for one year. In both cases, it is important to follow up following the allotted one or three years to confirm that the discharge was expunged; purging this from your record is not always automatic. If the nature of your offence was particularly serious, such as aggravated sexual assault with a weapon, rape, or sexual assault against a minor, you are unlikely to be eligible for a peace bond or discharge. With more serious charges, you will almost certainly face jail time, hefty fines, and a permanent criminal record, but there may still be alternative sentencing options to lessen the time you have to spend behind bars. Two of these options are intermittent sentences and suspended sentences.
Intermittent and Suspended Sentences
An intermittent sentence allows you to serve your sentence over the weekends so that you can spend the rest of the week outside of jail. This allows offenders to continue to work and earn an income while they complete their sentence. A suspended sentence, on the other hand, is similar to probation in that you are released from jail with certain conditions. But the conditions of a suspended sentence are typically quite strict, and the slightest violation of its terms will land you in jail.
Potential Defences Against Sexual Assault
The defences available to you in a sexual assault case will depend largely on the charges against you, but two of the most common defences are that the alleged victim consented to the act, or that you mistakenly believed the alleged victim had given consent. In either case, it is up to you — and your lawyer — to provide ample evidence to create a reasonable doubt about the charges against you.
The Psychological and Social Impact of a Conviction
A sexual assault conviction can have profound and lasting effects beyond the legal consequences. It can impact many areas of your personal and professional life, often creating challenges that extend far beyond the courtroom.
Employment, Housing, and Travel Restrictions
A criminal record for sexual assault can severely limit your employment opportunities, as many employers conduct background checks and may be hesitant to hire someone with such a conviction. Housing options can also be affected, with landlords potentially refusing applications from individuals with a criminal record. Additionally, a sentence can restrict your ability to travel internationally, as many countries deny entry to those with criminal histories, especially related to sexual offences.
Emotional and Mental Health Challenges
The stress and stigma associated with a sexual assault charge and conviction can take a heavy toll on mental health. Individuals often experience anxiety, depression, isolation, and difficulty trusting others. The social stigma may also strain relationships with family and friends, making emotional recovery even more challenging. It is crucial to seek professional support to navigate these challenges and protect your well-being during and after legal proceedings.
“Sexual assault charges carry serious consequences that can impact every aspect of a person’s life. It is crucial to have a skilled defence lawyer who understands the nuances of Ontario’s laws and can aggressively protect your rights at every stage of the process.”
False Allegations and Public Mischief
False allegations of sexual assault can have serious consequences for the accused, often causing significant damage to their reputation, relationships, and mental health. In Ontario, knowingly making a false accusation or providing misleading information to authorities can lead to charges of public mischief under Section 140 of the Criminal Code of Canada.
Public mischief occurs when someone intentionally causes the police or others to investigate a crime that did not happen or misleads authorities about the identity of the offender. This offence is taken seriously because it wastes valuable police resources and can unjustly harm innocent people.
If you believe you are a victim of false accusations, it is essential to work with an experienced defence lawyer who can help gather evidence, protect your rights, and challenge the prosecution’s case to ensure the truth is revealed.
Contact Vilkhov Law Today
If you have been charged with sexual assault, it is essential to seek legal counsel immediately. The highly-experienced and skilled legal team at Vilkhov Law will protect your rights and position you for the most favourable outcome possible. Having a conviction for any type of sex crime on your criminal record can literally ruin your life, negatively impacting your ability to get a job or housing for a lifetime. Now is not the time to cut corners or work with just any lawyer. Our criminal defence team has successfully defended countless clients against sexual assault and child pornography charges, and we understand the sensitive nature of these cases. We are not here to judge. We will work tirelessly to protect your rights, reputation, and freedom. Contact Vilkhov Law today for a free and confidential consultation about your case.
At Vilkhov Law, our team is here for you to help you access the legal services you need in the following areas:
Criminal Lawyers in Toronto
Criminal Lawyers in Etobicoke
Criminal Lawyers in Scarborough
Criminal Lawyers in Newmarket
Criminal Lawyers in Brampton
Criminal Lawyers in Mississauga
