Criminal Defence Strategies in Canada

For anyone facing a criminal charge in Canada, it’s absolutely essential to be able to strategize a viable criminal defence in order to better your chances of success during your trial.

It’s not enough to simply say, “I didn’t do it,” or otherwise claim innocence, no matter how truthful the sentiment may be – you and your criminal defence lawyer must convince the court that your sentiment is valid and can be proven as such, or, that the Crown prosecution’s evidence and narrative regarding your case are flawed.

In preparation for your trial and your criminal defence, learning about the most common criminal defence strategies in Canada is key.

Alibi

The word “alibi” is derived from the Latin word “elsewhere” – the purpose of your alibi defence is to assert that you as the accused could not have committed the crime due to being elsewhere at the time.

During trial, the alibi defence revolves around subjective evidence rather than objective evidence, as it can usually preclude the case from ever reaching trial. For example, police can easily verify a bank robbery suspect’s claim that they were seeing their probation officer at the time of the crime.

In order to be effective – and to encourage dismissal of your charges pre-trial – a viable alibi defence should be presented to the court as early as possible. While alibi disclosure should be made early to provide police time to investigate your claim, the Canadian Supreme Court rules that an untimely disclosure during trial does not invalidate it – instead, as per R. v. Cleghorn [1995] S.C.R. 175, the high court holds that improper or untimely disclosure “can only weaken alibi evidence; it cannot exclude it.”

Raising of Reasonable Doubt

This defence is most often carried out to raise doubts about the validity of the evidence against you and the overall narrative of your charges. The more doubts a criminal defence lawyer can raise, the harder it becomes for the Crown to secure a conviction.

Canadian criminal law operates under the legal concept of “presumed innocent until proven guilty”. In proving that guilt, Crown prosecutors must provide evidence that a defendant committed the guilty act, or “actus reus” in Latin. Prosecutors must also prove that the criminal act was committed with intent or knowledge – “mens rea” for “guilty mind.” In addition, the legal threshold for proof must be established “beyond a reasonable doubt.”

The Supreme Court of Canada’s precedent-setting decisions on “reasonable doubt” hold that judges and juries do not need to be 100% certain of a defendant’s guilt. However, the high court established that guilt cannot be established on a belief that a defendant “probably” committed the crime. The court has also interpreted the beyond-a-reasonable doubt standard as being closer to a 100% certainty threshold than the “balance of probabilities” proof threshold used in civil cases.

Therefore, defence lawyers must take every opportunity during criminal trials to reduce the potential percentage of certainty when it comes to examining evidence. Rather than proving innocence, defence lawyers typically rely on disproving guilt by raising doubt. Of course, defence lawyers will also typically introduce innocence-supporting evidence, as this casts additional doubt on the Crown’s case.

Lack of Intent

The lack of intent defence acknowledges the commitment of the crime, but argues that it was justified or excusable. As an affirmative defence, the onus is on the defendant to prove the claim. Judges only allow such affirmative defences to be introduced during trial if there is enough evidence to establish an “air of reality” supporting the claim.

Defence lawyers use lack of intent to challenge the “mens rea” element of proving guilt that requires criminal acts to be committed with intent or knowledge. Without the proper intent or knowledge, a person cannot be held criminally responsible for their actions. Common lack of intent defence strategies include:

  • Mistake: Based on proving that the criminal act was committed on a mistake of fact. For example, arguing that a theft was committed because the defendant thought that the stolen item was theirs.
  • Duress: Codified by law, this defence relies on proving that a defendant committed the criminal act because they were under imminent threat of death or bodily harm. Under the criminal code, this defence cannot be used in cases involving 11 kinds of serious offences, including murder, arson, and sexual assault.
  • Mental incapacity: As codified in Section 16 of the Criminal Code, “[no] person is criminally responsible for an act committed … while suffering from a mental disorder that rendered the person incapable of appreciating the nature and quality of the act … or of knowing that it was wrong.”

Self Defence and Defence of Property

Codified under Section 34 of the Canadian Criminal Code, self-defence is one of the most well-known legal defences used in criminal law. This law specifically states that a person is not guilty of committing an offence if:

  • They believed that force or the threat of force was being used against them or another person.
  • Their defensive actions were taken to defend themselves or others from the use or threat of force.
  • Their defensive actions were reasonable under the circumstances.

During trial, self-defence can be raised as a defence strategy if the issue emerges during the presentation of physical evidence or the cross-examination of a witness. If the judge deems it a viable defence, Crown prosecutors must disprove the self-defence claim beyond a reasonable doubt. During trial, the success of self-defence typically hinges on the reasonableness of the defendant’s self-defence actions and the proportionality of the response to the threat.

Covered by Section 35 of the Code, the defence of property is also similar to self-defence.

Mistaken Identity

Lastly, the mistaken identity defence relies on raising reasonable doubt surrounding whether or not police correctly identified the offender.

This defence works best when charges are based primarily on eyewitness testimony; the reliability of eyewitness testimony is open to challenges based on numerous factors that criminal defence lawyers are adept at exploiting. Distance, lighting, memory, stress, and other elements can affect what a witness thought they saw – and, when more than one witness is involved, their accounts can often vary.

At the end of the day, working with a skilled lawyer is critical when it comes to solidifying your defence strategies in preparation for your criminal case. At Vilkhov Law, our team of professionals is here for you to help you every step of the way. Reach out to a member of our team today to schedule your consultation.

By |2023-08-11T10:32:52+00:00June 12th, 2023|Criminal Defence|

5/5 - (2 votes)

Criminal Lawyers Association
Toronnto Lawyers Association
Law Society of Ontario
Criminal Lawyers Association
Toronnto Lawyers Association
Law Society of Ontario
Excellent4.9 Based on 99 reviews fromDaniel SlobodkinDaniel Slobodkin ★★★★★ I have known Mr. Vilkhov in a professional and personal capacity for several years. Mr. Vilkhov is a well-respected and devoted criminal lawyer who prioritizes the success and livelihood of his clients. Mr. Vilkhov goes out of his way and makes time, at all times of day, to tend to the needs of his clients. Mr. Vilkhov is a diligent lawyer I would recommend to anyone dealing with a criminal matter. Well-spoken, confident, methodical and professional are qualities that only begin to scratch the surface of Mr. Vilkhov criminal law practice and his character at whole.Amina HuseynovaAmina Huseynova ★★★★★ I've known Igor professionally for a long time, one of the most dedicated criminal lawyers I have met. He gets amazing results for his clients and I would recommend anyone who is looking to hire him.maddy mmaddy m ★★★★★ I am international student in Canada, six months ago I was falsely accused of SA and I was charged. I had never dealt with all this in my life and I started looking for a lawyer. I spoke too more than 50 lawyers all over ontario and every lawyer I spoke to tried to scare me and told me that I am a dead meat here and this thing is definitely going to trial and were only interested in talking about their fees. Mr Vilkhov patiently heard my case and told me that there is a high possibility of getting the case withdrawn . He was straightforward and honest. He convinced me after one call that he is the right lawyer for me to retain. He charged a very reasonable fee which he let me pay in installments. He kept me well informed about my case in every stage. Mr. Vilkhov and Daniel from his team were my constant support. Every message and every phone call was answered.Mr Vilkhov got the charges withdrawn!!! My case was in a jurisdictions were cases like these never get withdrawn. But Mr. Vilkhov gave his best and got the charges withdrawn without any conditions. I cannot thank Vilkhov law professional for giving my life back! Mr. Vilkhov is very knowledgeable and he is the lawyer you need by your side when you need it the most! He wins when you need it the most! Thank you Vilkhov law corporation!Jay ModiJay Modi ★★★★★ Igor and his team exceeded my expectations, efficiently getting all charges dropped in my case. His timely responses, coupled with Daniel's eloquence, made for an exceptional first-time experience with a lawyer. They provided a unique blend of empathy and straightforwardness that instilled confidence throughout the legal process. Highly recommendable for anyone in need of a criminal justice lawyer.Naqib PopalNaqib Popal ★★★★★ I just left Brampton courthouse. I was acquitted of 11 charges after a long trial. Igor Vilkhov absolutely killed it during the entire trial. If it wasn’t for him, I would be going to jail. Thank you so much for your work, you ensured the truth came out. Thank you, you got me my life back.Chad AllanChad Allan ★★★★★ Igor got me an amazing deal, he was always communicating with me and updating me about my case, he got me the deal of a lifetime and I can’t him enough. If you are reading this and you are thinking about who to hire, just call him, he is the right lawyer for you.Jamie LewisJamie Lewis ★★★★★ If you need a lawyer who is actually going to work for you, and get results go with Igor at Vilkhov Law. He was very patient and understanding and knows his stuff. I was facing a huge fine which would have devastated me financially for years to come, but with his passionate submission to crown on my behalf he was able to get the fine reduced by 90%. His colleagues he works with are amazing too. Thank you so much for all of your help through this matter Igor! You truely have saved my future. I appreciate it beyond measure! All the best in the future!Akash TyagiAkash Tyagi ★★★★★ Hi all, When i just came to Canada, i got charged with SA, which was a nightmare for me where my so called friends left my side. Then by luck i got to know Mr. Igor and that day changed everything.Being new in a country could cost me a lot but with Igor’s genuine efforts to help me, saved my life.A big thanks to him and god bless him.Must recommended lawyer.Thanks a ton Igor.❤️ted ferreirated ferreira ★★★★★ I met Igor approximately two years ago when we met with him regarding SA charges against our son. Over that time Igor was always there to answer questions that we had, he was reassuring explaining that we had a strong case.From the beginning we were impressed with Igor's demeanor, he was always calm and to the point, he did his best to keep us on track with the facts.Thanks to Igor's thorough preparation he was able to get the SA charges stayed. I cannot tell you how incredible that feeling was.We owe so much to him.We highly recommend Igor to anyone needing Legal help, he will work tirelessly on your behalf.OKOLI MARKOKOLI MARK ★★★★★ Thank you Igor Vilkhov for helping me go through my legal case from the very beginning to the end. Igor's professional advice and approach to difficult legal matter is excellent and recommended, Case has been withdrawn from court!! 1 million thanks for the support throughout this process 🙏.Laura BeniaLaura Benia ★★★★★ Professional, honest and caring.Zafreenp PZafreenp P ★★★★★ Igor and his staff were amazing. They were quick and very assertive. Highly recommend them.Best OgunpoluBest Ogunpolu ★★★★★ He gave me great service very very great service. He caught my case with John gave me great advice. He was always there for me. Always answer my call and returned back. My call when it was messed. I recommend him he’s a very great lawyer knows what he’s doing.Gnrl_AnesthesiaGnrl_Anesthesia ★★★★★ I cannot express enough gratitude for the exceptional legal support I received from Igor, an extraordinary criminal lawyer who helped me overcome the toughest challenge of my life. His unwavering de