Criminal Defence Strategies in Canada

For anyone facing a criminal charge in Canada, it’s absolutely essential to be able to strategize a viable criminal defence in order to better your chances of success during your trial.

It’s not enough to simply say, “I didn’t do it,” or otherwise claim innocence, no matter how truthful the sentiment may be – you and your criminal defence lawyer must convince the court that your sentiment is valid and can be proven as such, or, that the Crown prosecution’s evidence and narrative regarding your case are flawed.

In preparation for your trial and your criminal defence, learning about the most common criminal defence strategies in Canada is key.

Alibi

The word “alibi” is derived from the Latin word “elsewhere” – the purpose of your alibi defence is to assert that you as the accused could not have committed the crime due to being elsewhere at the time.

During trial, the alibi defence revolves around subjective evidence rather than objective evidence, as it can usually preclude the case from ever reaching trial. For example, police can easily verify a bank robbery suspect’s claim that they were seeing their probation officer at the time of the crime.

In order to be effective – and to encourage dismissal of your charges pre-trial – a viable alibi defence should be presented to the court as early as possible. While alibi disclosure should be made early to provide police time to investigate your claim, the Canadian Supreme Court rules that an untimely disclosure during trial does not invalidate it – instead, as per R. v. Cleghorn [1995] S.C.R. 175, the high court holds that improper or untimely disclosure “can only weaken alibi evidence; it cannot exclude it.”

Raising of Reasonable Doubt

This defence is most often carried out to raise doubts about the validity of the evidence against you and the overall narrative of your charges. The more doubts a criminal defence lawyer can raise, the harder it becomes for the Crown to secure a conviction.

Canadian criminal law operates under the legal concept of “presumed innocent until proven guilty”. In proving that guilt, Crown prosecutors must provide evidence that a defendant committed the guilty act, or “actus reus” in Latin. Prosecutors must also prove that the criminal act was committed with intent or knowledge – “mens rea” for “guilty mind.” In addition, the legal threshold for proof must be established “beyond a reasonable doubt.”

The Supreme Court of Canada’s precedent-setting decisions on “reasonable doubt” hold that judges and juries do not need to be 100% certain of a defendant’s guilt. However, the high court established that guilt cannot be established on a belief that a defendant “probably” committed the crime. The court has also interpreted the beyond-a-reasonable doubt standard as being closer to a 100% certainty threshold than the “balance of probabilities” proof threshold used in civil cases.

Therefore, defence lawyers must take every opportunity during criminal trials to reduce the potential percentage of certainty when it comes to examining evidence. Rather than proving innocence, defence lawyers typically rely on disproving guilt by raising doubt. Of course, defence lawyers will also typically introduce innocence-supporting evidence, as this casts additional doubt on the Crown’s case.

Lack of Intent

The lack of intent defence acknowledges the commitment of the crime, but argues that it was justified or excusable. As an affirmative defence, the onus is on the defendant to prove the claim. Judges only allow such affirmative defences to be introduced during trial if there is enough evidence to establish an “air of reality” supporting the claim.

Defence lawyers use lack of intent to challenge the “mens rea” element of proving guilt that requires criminal acts to be committed with intent or knowledge. Without the proper intent or knowledge, a person cannot be held criminally responsible for their actions. Common lack of intent defence strategies include:

  • Mistake: Based on proving that the criminal act was committed on a mistake of fact. For example, arguing that a theft was committed because the defendant thought that the stolen item was theirs.
  • Duress: Codified by law, this defence relies on proving that a defendant committed the criminal act because they were under imminent threat of death or bodily harm. Under the criminal code, this defence cannot be used in cases involving 11 kinds of serious offences, including murder, arson, and sexual assault.
  • Mental incapacity: As codified in Section 16 of the Criminal Code, “[no] person is criminally responsible for an act committed … while suffering from a mental disorder that rendered the person incapable of appreciating the nature and quality of the act … or of knowing that it was wrong.”

Self Defence and Defence of Property

Codified under Section 34 of the Canadian Criminal Code, self-defence is one of the most well-known legal defences used in criminal law. This law specifically states that a person is not guilty of committing an offence if:

  • They believed that force or the threat of force was being used against them or another person.
  • Their defensive actions were taken to defend themselves or others from the use or threat of force.
  • Their defensive actions were reasonable under the circumstances.

During trial, self-defence can be raised as a defence strategy if the issue emerges during the presentation of physical evidence or the cross-examination of a witness. If the judge deems it a viable defence, Crown prosecutors must disprove the self-defence claim beyond a reasonable doubt. During trial, the success of self-defence typically hinges on the reasonableness of the defendant’s self-defence actions and the proportionality of the response to the threat.

Covered by Section 35 of the Code, the defence of property is also similar to self-defence.

Mistaken Identity

Lastly, the mistaken identity defence relies on raising reasonable doubt surrounding whether or not police correctly identified the offender.

This defence works best when charges are based primarily on eyewitness testimony; the reliability of eyewitness testimony is open to challenges based on numerous factors that criminal defence lawyers are adept at exploiting. Distance, lighting, memory, stress, and other elements can affect what a witness thought they saw – and, when more than one witness is involved, their accounts can often vary.

At the end of the day, working with a skilled lawyer is critical when it comes to solidifying your defence strategies in preparation for your criminal case. At Vilkhov Law, our team of professionals is here for you to help you every step of the way. Reach out to a member of our team today to schedule your consultation.

By |2023-08-11T10:32:52+00:00June 12th, 2023|Criminal Defence|

5/5 - (3 votes)

Criminal Lawyers Association
Toronnto Lawyers Association
Law Society of Ontario
Criminal Lawyers Association
Toronnto Lawyers Association
Law Society of Ontario
Excellent5.0 Based on 160 reviews fromSean MacNeilSean MacNeil ★★★★★ I cannot recommend Igor's Law Firm highly enough! From start to finish, they took care of absolutely everything, making a stressful situation feel manageable. They ensured I was thoroughly prepared for every step, patiently explaining the process and what to expect.What truly sets this firm apart is Igor's uncanny ability to pick the right people for the right moment. This meant I never had to worry about his judgment; my faith in him and his team was incredibly well placed.When it came to my case, they didn't hesitate to take it on and provided invaluable support leading up to and during the actual court date. My representation on the day, Jackie, was beyond prepared – exactly the kind of sharp, knowledgeable lawyer you want fiercely advocating for you. Her meticulous preparation and strategic thinking were truly impressive.Behind the scenes, Daniel was instrumental in facilitating the flow of information, making sure everything got to the right people efficiently. And a huge shoutout to Joel for his incredible ability to recall and pull relevant, even obscure, case law at precisely the right moment – a testament to his deep expertise.The entire team at Igor's Law Firm operates with professionalism, dedication, and a genuine commitment to their clients. If you're looking for a legal team that truly has your back, look no further.Elijah L.Elijah L. ★★★★★ I had a great experience working with Attorney Igor Vilkhov and his law clerk Daniel Slobodkin. I am an attorney for criminal law and administrative law in California. They previously represented a client of mine about 2 years ago in a serious criminal matter. Thanks to their excellent advocacy and hard work, the charges were withdrawn by the court due to no reasonable prospect of conviction. Their hard work helped bring about a just outcome and absolve my client of the charges.Recently this month, I (as well as my client’s separate firm) needed access to my client’s past criminal case materials for another administrative matter. Mr. Vilkhov and Mr. Slobodkin were extremely helpful and professional in providing the necessary documents and court transcripts. Their prompt assistance and continued support, even years after the case concluded, truly stood out. Mr. Vilkhov was very professional and courteous and his law clerk Daniel was incredibly helpful and friendly, especially toward my client. Daniel also assisted me with filling out the court transcript order form since I am not too familiar with the Canadian court process, titles, numbers or labels.Their professionalism, responsiveness, and dedication to their clients are commendable, even years after my client’s case was concluded. I highly recommend Igor Vilkhov and Daniel Slobodkin to anyone in need of skilled and trustworthy legal representation in criminal defense.Lucia GurzauLucia Gurzau ★★★★★ I had an outstanding experience working with Igor Vilkhov. From our first consultation to the final resolution of my case, they demonstrated exceptional professionalism, deep legal knowledge, and genuine care for my situation. They communicated clearly, responded promptly, and always kept me informed throughout the process. Thanks to their dedication and expertise, we achieved a successful outcome. I highly recommend Igor Vilkhov to anyone in need of reliable and effective legal representation.BillyBilly ★★★★★ Igor is an unreal lawyer to say the least. Igor is a skilled attorney that is personable and reasonable. He was kind enough to explain the process and got me the results I needed. Would absolutely recommend him, excellent criminal lawyer.Ken ThamKen Tham ★★★★★ I cannot express how wonderful it was to work with and be represented by Igor and his team. Right from the start, Igor showed he cared - by listening, showing compassion and empathy for my situation, yet being fully transparent and honest about the process. He answered any and all of my questions and made me feel very secure and at ease. I got the result I wanted and Igor was true to his word in how things would play out. I would not hesitate to call upon Igor again, if needed, and would certainly recommend him. Thanks Igor!B KhanB Khan ★★★★★ Randy RaczRandy Racz ★★★★★ Lucas DeanLucas Dean ★★★★★ Incredibly talented and hard working team of lawyers in all of Ontario, and possibly the country. I cannot properly convey how extraordinary the team at Vilkhov law is. Igor was always willing to take my calls and alleviate my concerns. Joel and Jackie did tremendous work on my trial and spent countless hours working to ensure I was properly prepared for anything.I spent 6 months incarcerated at Toronto South Detention and Igor and his team were always willing to take my calls and even visited me while I was in jail.I am happy to state that I was acquitted of the most serious charges, and received a discharge for the lesser charges. My matters will be finalized shortly and I cannot wait to be free to live my life once more.To Igor, Joel, Jacklyn, and Daniel:Thank you for everything. I wish you all the very best in your pursuits and I will be sure to recommend you as often as possible.Mukesh SethiMukesh Sethi ★★★★★ Igor, provided exceptional legal representation, demonstrating expertise, professionalism, and dedication throughout my case. His strategic approach and deep understanding of criminal law led to a favourable outcome. I highly recommend Igor to anyone in need of a skilled and reliable criminal defence attorney.matthew jmatthew j ★★★★★ I was charged for the very serious offence Igor and his team got me Got my charges acquitted and I was free after 31 months, including a trial, Igor and his team are wonderful at what they do. Highly recommend couldn’t thank Igor enough.Joe OroszJoe Orosz ★★★★★ Igor did an amazing job. Was looking at 4 years 3 charges. Not guilty on all counts. I'd recommend him highly. He assured my freedom, he will do the same for you.Mehboob PatelMehboob Patel ★★★★★ E ME M ★★★★★ Igor is, without a doubt, one of the top lawyers in the country. When I approached him with my case, I was uncertain about the outcome. However, Igor's exceptional support and guidance alleviated my concerns. He was always available to answer my questions, and his flexible payment plan was a huge relief.What impressed me most was Igor's unwavering confidence and commitment. He assured me that he never backs down from trials, and his reputation precedes him. This is what kept me at peace through out the case.Throughout the process, Igor handled my case with utmost professionalism, keeping me informed every step of the way. His office was incredibly helpful, providing regular updates and ensuring a seamless experience.I had 2 charges which have severe consequences but the outcome of my case exceeded my expectations, thanks to Igor's expertise and dedication. I couldn't recommend him more highly, especially for those facing criminal cases. Igor truly goes above and beyond, and his services are unparalleled.x NoVAx NoVA ★★★★★ Igor did amazing job, I was very stressed out when I found out I had been charged with SA but every step of the Igor was there for me and was looking out for my best interest. He was always responsive and kept me up to date with all updates given to him and directly to me, if he wasn’t available he always had someone update me. Got me off my charges and helped me save jail time. Igor is the guy you need if you’re involved in any sort of similar situationforrzen Sherzadforrzen Sherzad ★★★★★ Dear Igor, I just wanted to take a moment to express my heartfelt gratitude for everything you’ve done for us. Your hard work and dedication in getting my husband released from jail mean the world to me. I’m so incredibly happy right now, and I truly believe you are the best lawyer ever!Your expertise and support throughout this process have been invaluable, and I can’t thank you enough. I will definitely be referring you to all my friends and family, and I’ll be leaving a 5-star review to share how amazing you are. Thank you again for everything! 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ we are so grateful for you thank you so much Igor you saved Jerome life your are truly the greatest!!!Michie FedericoMichie Federico ★★★★★ Igor and his team were absolutely amazing in helping my daughter out with everything. There were easy to get a hold off and there work is absolutely amazing I highly recommend him and his team.Tony OhTony Oh ★★★★★ Absolutely exceptional! My lawyer provided unwavering support, professionalism, and expertise throughout my case. Igor guided me every step of the way, ensuring I felt heard and protected. I couldn’t have asked for a better advocate. Highly recommended!nnn nnnnnn nnn ★★★★★ I'm very glad that Igor Vilkhov was my lawyer in solving my difficult problems. He is a real high-class professional. Thanks to Igor and his team ( special thanks to Daniel Slobodsky). My case was successfully completed. Excellent professional work with positive results. Highest recommendations! Roman M.Richard HyltonRichard Hylton ★★★★★ I cannot thank Igor enough for his amazing service. I was facing a serious charge that felt overwhelming. But Igor’s calm demeanour and level headed approach to my case gave me reassurance.Thanks to his amazing work everything was completely withdrawn, which allowed me to reclaim my life. I feel free to move forward without the weight of this hanging on my head. Thank God for Igor’s services! If you need a criminal lawyer, hire him!Ryan WiltonRyan Wilton ★★★★★ Igor Vilkhov and his associate Joel Prajs has been an absolutely amazing lawyers to work with, they've saved me copious amounts of grief on my legal matters.Their diligence to my matter and their ability to work with me and my schedule were greatly appreciated.I'd give them higher than 5 star rating if I could, my new number 1 lawyer!!Dennis ParkDennis Park ★★★★★ Igor is an absolute fantastic lawyer and I would highly recommend. I was facing some serious charges and Igor not only got all my charges withdrawn, he was very caring and informative through out the whole process. I owe him very dearly for getting me a second chance at life.Jodi HixonJodi Hixon ★★★★★ My name is Gary Hixon I've had Igor as my lawyer, and he did nothing but worked on my case and he got me worried at first , but because of COVID the first time I actually met him was when he hit my case out of the ball park. He's a great man I recommend him too all. Thank you Igor.Big DOWNEYYYBig DOWNEYYY ★★★★★ Greatness!!!! Mr.Igor Vilkhov and his team did a tremendous job on my stabbing case! He saved my life today I was facing years in the penitentiary for assault and he literally got it reduced to 2 years house arrest. He was an absolute pleasure to work with has a great attitude & I highly recommend him to everyone looking for a defense lawyer. He is definitely one of the TOP LAWYERS in Toronto! Thank you so muchjs_loader

CONTACT US

“Caring, honest, and highly knowledgeable.”

Contact Igor for a Free Consultation!

Please contact us online for a free consultation.
Go to Top